Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? - Printable Version -Shoutbox (https://shoutbox.menthix.net) +-- Forum: MsgHelp Archive (/forumdisplay.php?fid=58) +--- Forum: Messenger Plus! for Live Messenger (/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +---- Forum: WLM Plus! General (/forumdisplay.php?fid=23) +----- Thread: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? (/showthread.php?tid=32201) Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by Berglund on 09-27-2004 at 09:32 PM
Hello Everyone! RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by MC Inferno on 09-27-2004 at 09:34 PM
Not quite. MP!3.20 comes with an OPTIONAL sponsor, and if you change your mind, you can even get rid of it / add it on again RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by Berglund on 09-27-2004 at 09:40 PM Thnx for your quick answar.... But what is this "sponsor" thing anyway? RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by Tochjo on 09-27-2004 at 09:44 PM
The sponsor program has been added to let Patchou (the creator of the program) continue to work at Messenger Plus! daily; he has no full time job, but spends almost all his time programming Messenger Plus!. He thought this was the best way to keep the program freeware and still make a living. RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by MC Inferno on 09-27-2004 at 09:45 PM
The program makers pay Patchou (the creator of MP!3) to include the program in his installation, and thats how he gets his wages. In comparision to most programs like it, its a very light and stipped down version. RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by CookieRevised on 09-27-2004 at 09:46 PM So in short words, it is a very small piece of adware (which is very different from spyware) RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by Fred Greg on 09-28-2004 at 09:41 AM
The version of LOP installed with Plus! is indeed quite limited & stripped down, but it does hijack your IE settings & has the possibility of updating itself & opening you up to security concerns. RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by CookieRevised on 09-28-2004 at 10:32 AM
quote:No, it isn't... It has always been very easy, and always been the same: just uninstall Plus! and follow the intructions (closing every browserwindow, entering the check-number, ...) RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by user27089 on 09-28-2004 at 10:34 AM THe piece of adware is very compact, and won't do a lot of damage, if you do install it by accident, it can be uninstalled easily, by Uninstalling Plus! Completely, and Reinstalling and not accepting the sponsor program RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by Fred Greg on 09-28-2004 at 01:45 PM
quote:CookieRevised, you are someone who knows all those ins & outs, all about Plus!'s version of LOP, etc. Before I knew just what LOP was, I had enormous trouble getting rid of it. Once I realised it was the Plus! sponsor program, it was relatively easy to get rid of. But this was the third time I'd had it.The other two, uninstalling Plus! didn't work, because I'd used Ad-Aware once, & changed IE settings & rooted it out another time. The third time, the fact that I'd not managed to uninstall it the first two times, along with various registry changes - random-string sturtup item's have a funny tendency to be viruses or spyway - completely disabled the Plus!-bundled LOP uninstaller. I found out it was a harmless version coming with Plus! near the end of this episode. The reinstall w/ LOP, uninstall both, reboot, then reinstall w/out LOP didn't work... I had to root it right out, & this is LOP - it's not an easy thing to remove manually; in fact, I'm sure it'd be "well-nigh impossible" for most people. Once I did finally root it out, eveything went back to normal as far as Plus!, LOP, & uninstallation go. But I have to be careful with Ad-Aware etc.; I can't just exclude LOP, because I might get one of the normal versions. No matter what you say or how cut back it is, it's still LOP, & behaves as such. One tiny change & it's ununistallable. It also prevents you shutting down the process iexplore.exe; it respawns with another name if you kill it's own process, & reacts to anything & everything the way a virus/trojan would - it creates renamed copies & hides itself away, while making sure you didn't stop/alter the one you tried to. It changes, disguises itself (Yes, it does - All those redirected shortcuts & funny names), & prevents the average user knowing anything about it other than that their browser has apparently been hijacked w/out their permission (Kinda implied in the word "hijacked," I know.)! All this may seem off the point, but if you knew nothing about LOP, or worse yet the reputation of it's nastier cousins, you'd go after all the anti-spyware/adware you could lay your virtual hands on! And once you've touched it, you've got problems when it comes to for removal. If you ran an anti-adware program, you've got no chance. In these cases, simply performing Patchou's removal procedure might not work, as LOP has changed & spread. I realise the need for a sponsor - if Patchou works on Plus! full-time, as he does, then Patchou deserves the money. But that doesn't mean that LOP is in any way a harmless piece of flotsam. It's, & I almost quote traxor, without changing what he says, "a compact piece of adware which won't cause much damage." It is adware, I concede, not spyware, but it's from C2Media; they have a disturbing attitude that privacy & personal choice don't matter one whit. Look at what they gave Patchou in the first few releases including LOP - it even changed the computer name. He may have made them stop that, but the attitude remains, & they shouldn't be trusted too far by anyone with any idea what malware is. For all these reasons, I stand by my earlier statement that you should always say No to the sponsor program. Patchou needs an income, so leave it there, but as long as I'm not saying this on his behalf (That'd leave him broke & I don't think he deserves that), then No's the better option. Vehemently, Fred Greg. Please note: I realise I am putting forward an extreme viewpoint - I make no apologies for the fact. I feel very strongly about anything unauthorised. I do, however, apologise if I've offended anyone at all. I've no intention to do that. If that's the case, sorry. RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by CookieRevised on 09-28-2004 at 02:41 PM
I'm not attacking your point of view, you have the right for that. And I'm not aguing about what it realy does (although the things you've said seem like the sponsor is the product from hell although I could give you examples of normal (non-malware) programs which act just the same.) RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by Fred Greg on 09-29-2004 at 05:03 AM
I realise how much damage Ad-Aware & Spybot S&D can cause - you're right, normal users shouldn't run them. But that doesn't change the fact that many will. RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by eckocomplex on 09-29-2004 at 05:17 AM Patchou has done the right thing in making it optional. You can't argue that, because most [evil] software developers install spware without you even knowing, despite not giving you the option. Patchou has to make a living too . RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by Patchou on 09-29-2004 at 06:14 AM
You base your spyware arguments on the fact that the sponsorsoftware does it best to survive on the systemwhere it's installed. It is true that it adds many weird links that all ultiamtely go to the same search page, and the reason is simple: anti-adware programs. If software liek adaware didn't exist, they wouldn't have to do this. If a popular application was detecting my software and trying to remove it auomatically, I would try to overcome the protection too. The fact is that when an adware liek the one I distribute is properly installed (by asking the user before doing anything and by not displaying things like"click here to win" to forcean install), the software is completely legitimate and in my opinion, companies like adaware do not have the right to remove it from a computer. Most of my users are not interested in computer stuff, they're just interested in getting the program they want, for free. and that's what they get with Messenger Plus!. Mostof them don't care to install the sponsor because they understand (or don't even bother to wonder) that they get a couple of ads in exchange for some free services. That's what you get on every search engine nowadays, that's what you get on TV, on radio, everywhere! why would it be any different for software? I don't see people destroying advertisements in the street under the pretext that they don't want to see them everyday while taking the bus. RE: Messenger PLUS! = Spyware? by Fred Greg on 09-30-2004 at 09:28 AM
OK, I'm convinced of your reasoning. It's fair enough. But you should make it clearer, if that's possible without infuriating lop.com, exactly what is being asked (info with & around the LOP EULA). |