Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock - Printable Version
-Shoutbox (https://shoutbox.menthix.net)
+-- Forum: MsgHelp Archive (/forumdisplay.php?fid=58)
+--- Forum: Messenger Plus! for Live Messenger (/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+---- Forum: WLM Plus! Bug Reports (/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+----- Thread: Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock (/showthread.php?tid=46839)
Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock by lopardo on 06-25-2005 at 06:13 PM
I found a bug with the Boss Protection and Messenger Lock features, check this out.
Step by step example:
- Sign in into Messenger, go to Plus! > Preferences > Privacy Protection.
- Make sure "Enable the Boss Protection feature" is checked, there's a shortcut assigned, and the "Status while hiding" is something like Busy.
- Click OK to save Plus settings.
- Set your status to Appear offline.
- Press the Boss Protection shortcut. As you now are "Busy", your contacts can see you.
Also, with StuffPlug's polygamy option enabled, I opened two Messenger instances, signed into two different accounts, and set the same Boss Protection and Messenger Lock shortcuts.
Calling the shortcuts worked fine, both instances were hidden. But if I disable Boss Protection and Messenger Lock in one of the accounts, then it stops working for both of them.
OK, I hope everything I explained is understandable
See you,
lopardo.
BTW, Patch, how do you mute Messenger's sounds while the user is in Boss Protection mode? It's interesting for a plugin I'm making.
RE: Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock by CookieRevised on 06-25-2005 at 06:54 PM
quote:This is not a bug, but by design. Though, it would indeed be good to see a registry setting for this (something like "BossProtectionAlways"; along the line of the already existing AutoAwayAlways).
Originally posted by lopardo
I found a bug with the Boss Protection and Messenger Lock features, check this out.
(...)
I think MsgPlus shouldn't change the user status if the current status is Appear offline, as this mode is different from other statuses.
quote:correct, but reported before... (although I can't seem to find the thread in an instant)
Originally posted by lopardo
Also, with StuffPlug's polygamy option enabled, I opened two Messenger instances, signed into two different accounts, and set the same Boss Protection and Messenger Lock shortcuts.
Calling the shortcuts worked fine, both instances were hidden. But if I disable Boss Protection and Messenger Lock in one of the accounts, then it stops working for both of them.
RE: Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock by RaceProUK on 06-25-2005 at 07:01 PM
Is it maybe because Boss Protection and Messenger Lock are designed to work on all instances of Messenger? Would make sense.
Either that, or Plus! just isn't designed for polygamy.
RE: Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock by lopardo on 06-25-2005 at 07:36 PM
quote:Yeah, but it's not the same as AutoAwayAlways. It doesn't make sense as "hidden" reg. setting. I think it's a bug, "appear offline" isn't a status like the others (people can't see you while you "appear offline").
Originally posted by CookieRevised
This is not a bug, but by design. Though, it would indeed be good to see a registry setting for this (something like "BossProtectionAlways"; along the line of the already existing AutoAwayAlways).
quote:Huh? It works on all instances (as it should), but it stops working on all instances if one of them has Boss Protection or Messenger Lock disabled (it should probably hide or lock only one in this case). Maybe the Boss Protection should be global.
Originally posted by raceprouk
Is it maybe because Boss Protection and Messenger Lock are designed to work on all instances of Messenger? Would make sense.
Either that, or Plus! just isn't designed for polygamy.
RE: RE: Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock by CookieRevised on 06-25-2005 at 07:48 PM
quote:Nope it is by design; It would be a very stupid and strange bug to be overlooked otherwise (IMO). "offline" is a status just like any other status and when you activate the boss protection, the boss protection simply changes your status, it doesn't check what your status is atm.
Originally posted by lopardo
quote:Yeah, but it's not the same as AutoAwayAlways. It doesn't make sense as "hidden" reg. setting. I think it's a bug, "appear offline" isn't a status like the others (people can't see you while you "appear offline").
Originally posted by CookieRevised
This is not a bug, but by design. Though, it would indeed be good to see a registry setting for this (something like "BossProtectionAlways"; along the line of the already existing AutoAwayAlways).
It is exactly like "AutoAwayAlways" because that also defines/limits the function to only a specific status which must be/must not be in action. If this isn't added as a "hidden" registry key, then "AutoAwayAlways" must also be made into a proper "not hidden" option IMHO.
RE: Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock by Sunshine on 06-25-2005 at 08:06 PM
quote:I think you mean this one:
Originally posted by CookieRevised
correct, but reported before... (although I can't seem to find the thread in an instant)
Polygamy + Boss Protection Bug
(i remember the two of us trying to figure that one out
)
RE: Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock by lopardo on 06-25-2005 at 08:07 PM
It's always hard to discuss with you
quote:How do you know?
Originally posted by CookieRevised
Nope it is by design
quote:Nobody's perfect. Patchou is human and could have simply forgotten about this, if he was perfect we wouldn't have this subforum.
Originally posted by CookieRevised
It would be a very stupid and strange bug to be overlooked otherwise (IMO)
quote:I saw this one coming... Yes, technically, it's just another status, but it's the only one in which your contacts can't see you or talk to you, so it's a special status. Therefore, the Boss Protection and Messenger Lock features should check before changing your status. If you're in offline mode, it's because you don't want to talk or be seen.
Originally posted by CookieRevised
"offline" is a status just like any other status
Let's say I wanna go the bathroom and a friend of mine is here. I lock Messenger with a password so he can't use it. I was in offline mode because I didn't want to talk to someone or I didn't want someone to know I was online for some reason
. Now my contacts see I'm online. But I do want MsgPlus to change my status when I'm in online mode and use this feature.quote:That's why I'm posting this.
Originally posted by CookieRevised
the boss protection simply changes your status, it doesn't check what your status is atm
quote:It's not the same. It does something similar, but the context is different. Why should that "be made into a proper "not hidden" option"? They are different things.
Originally posted by CookieRevised
It is exactly like "AutoAwayAlways" because that also defines/limits the function to only a specific status which must be/must not be in action. If this isn't added as a "hidden" registry key, then "AutoAwayAlways" must also be made into a proper "not hidden" option IMHO.
When you make a program, you have to think which options you want to put in the GUI. You have to draw the line somewhere, you have to get a balance between functionality and easy of use. Otherwise you get a dialog with a thousand checkboxes for trivial options that make the important ones hard to find.
IMHO, the best solution for this would be if the Boss Protection and the Messenger Lock features only changed to the selected status if the current one wasn't "Appear offline". Then there could be a reg key to put it back as it is now.
RE: Bug in Boss Protection and Messenger Lock by CookieRevised on 06-25-2005 at 08:29 PM
To answer both questions of "how do you know it is by design" and the (not) adding as a "hidden" setting: one of my arguments is that this beheviour was exatly the same for the auto-away as it is now for the Boss Protection, until Patchou added that registry key... Both that situation and this one is the same; it both will limit an action to only a specific status or statusses.
quote:Fictious quote of how it could be:
2.21.56 Version - 20/09/2003
* By default, the "auto away" feature now changes your status online when it is Online or Idle. If you want to keep the way the feature worked before, use the AutoAwayAlways registry setting
quote:
3.xx.xxx Version - xx/xx/2005
* By default, the Boss Protection feature now changes your status only when you're online. If you want to keep the way the feature worked before, use the BossProtectionAlways registry setting
anyways, we both agree it will be a good feature, no matter how it is implemented, right?
