Shoutbox

MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! - Printable Version

-Shoutbox (https://shoutbox.menthix.net)
+-- Forum: MsgHelp Archive (/forumdisplay.php?fid=58)
+--- Forum: Messenger Plus! for Live Messenger (/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+---- Forum: WLM Plus! General (/forumdisplay.php?fid=23)
+----- Thread: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! (/showthread.php?tid=48814)

MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by DJeX on 08-11-2005 at 05:43 PM

I started my comp up today and got this message from my microsoft antispyware.

[Image: mspb.JPG]

I checked to always ignore this treat as seen in pic.


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by MoRiA on 08-11-2005 at 06:14 PM

"Now"? That has always been its behaviour... And it's just doing it's job to be honest, and better than the other anti spyware programs available, for that matter.


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by absorbation on 08-11-2005 at 06:15 PM

they relased a new beta on july 31st for me. i had to update :P
now it does this :S


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by TylerG on 08-11-2005 at 06:54 PM

It has always detected it for me.  Just ignore it, it isn't a big deal really:S


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Anubis on 08-11-2005 at 07:02 PM

More information about Microsoft Anti-Spyware and the false readings for Messenger Plus! can be found here:

Microsoft's Anti-spyware Software...
Microsoft® Windows AntiSpyware (Beta)
MS Antispyware says Messenger Plus is adware
Microsoft ANtiSpyware Beta1 - False detections (not only Plus!)
Unless you are saying that it always appears no matter how many times you tell it that it's to be ignored.
Does it continue to appear after every restart? After you click to ignore the threat and then click Yes and Allow does it ever come up again? If Not, then this is old news.


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by mwe99 on 08-11-2005 at 07:09 PM

Im not really keen on it, mainly because the other users get attacked by allow or ignore boxes when they logon... i got rid of it


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by DJeX on 08-11-2005 at 07:12 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Absorbation
they relased a new beta on july 31st for me. i had to update :P
now it does this :S

I did the same as Absorbation, so I thought it was something new because it never did it to me before.

RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Patchou on 08-14-2005 at 06:22 PM

Well, that is new...... what the hell is that and since when msgplus.exe is a threat to anybody? I'm going to contact MS about this and if they don't do something about it, this time, I will. This is outrageous.

Thanks for reporting.


RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by alexp2_ad on 08-14-2005 at 09:49 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Patchou
Well, that is new...... what the hell is that and since when msgplus.exe is a threat to anybody? I'm going to contact MS about this and if they don't do something about it, this time, I will. This is outrageous.

Thanks for reporting.

Yeah, that's just stupid, a high threat level for something that (since it's already installed) does no harm...

You kick they asses! ;)
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by NiteMare on 08-14-2005 at 09:52 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Patchou
if they don't do something about it, this time, I will.

hmmm what whould you do?, sue?:P
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Chrono on 08-14-2005 at 10:38 PM

quote:
Originally posted by NiteMare
quote:
Originally posted by Patchou
if they don't do something about it, this time, I will.

hmmm what whould you do?, sue?:P
it's a possibility i guess... it would be nice, it would be on television :banana:
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by L. Coyote on 08-15-2005 at 12:19 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Chrono
it's a possibility i guess... it would be nice, it would be on television :banana:
:o We'll be on TV? If they take a screenshot of the forums, I'll end up in it! :banana:

Anyway, I tried MSAS for a couple of hours, a long time ago, and it's just plain dumb. I don't know how people can say it's the best anti-spyware, when SpyBot S&D and others can find more things related to spyware and leave alone the innocent programs.
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Death001 on 08-15-2005 at 02:13 AM

it would have something to do with the ads that you can optionally install

msgplus has always been detected by ms antispyware but only recently as been made a high risk

its in the news on mess.be


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Patchou on 08-15-2005 at 03:30 AM

Note that the software has not been made "high risk", it's still considered moderate, they just added code to detect and remove the files everytime they are run, and not only during scans.


RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by lawdka0z on 08-15-2005 at 04:39 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Patchou
I'm going to contact MS about this and if they don't do something about it, this time, I will. This is outrageous.


What, like removing the adware? Face the facts, your in denial about this, your software is causing problems for people, they dont add these ratings for nothing.
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by albert on 08-15-2005 at 04:51 AM

quote:
Originally posted by lawdka0z
What, like removing the adware? Face the facts, your in denial about this, your software is causing problems for people, they dont add these ratings for nothing.

If I can say, it is causing problems for ppl who do not real any EULAS, it is said in the setup 3 times that there is an OPTIONAL sponsor program that you can choose to install or not, enough discussion about this, people simpy have to read.
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Patchou on 08-15-2005 at 05:13 AM

Again, I must insist on the facts: removing msgplus.exe WILL NOT remove the sponsor nor the way the sponsor is installed in the first place. It does not serve any purposes whatsoever except maybe "you're a bad boy, we'll remove all your stuff from our user's computers as a result and consider it as a threat, just in case".


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by L. Coyote on 08-15-2005 at 05:14 AM

quote:
Originally posted by lawdka0z
YES, AND MICROSOFT IS ACTING LIKE A BABYSITTER? WHATS YOUR POINT? M$ ARE DOING THERE JOBS.
Avoid "yelling" (using all CAPITALS) as it is against the forum rules. :)



MSAS (Microsoft Anti-Spyware) should not remove Messenger Plus! nor make it difficult for the user to completely remove the sponsor or other files. This is what we're discussing here. It's not MSAS's job to do this, since MsgPlus! and its sponsor are in no way harmful (I can say this because in the year or so I've been using MsgPlus!, I never had a problem with uninstalling the sponsor or using it).
RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by lawdka0z on 08-15-2005 at 05:15 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Patchou
Again, I must insist on the facts: removing msgplus.exe WILL NOT remove the sponsor nor the way the sponsor is installed in the first place. It does not serve any purposes whatsoever except maybe "you're a bad boy, we'll remove all your stuff from our user's computers as a result and consider it as a threat, just in case".


Must I make this point again,

IF Microsoft dont tag the whole msgplus package as unsafe, then you could just find a new adware provider and evade the bad rating!

Why should M$ give you that option?
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by alexp2_ad on 08-15-2005 at 08:57 AM

To be honest, perhaps you should remove the bundler...

I know that's how you make money, and thats all fair enough.  But you could maybe add 20 seconds of adverts at the end of the setup (that would reach more people too, since everyone would see them).  Or have adverts on the preference pages, I'm sure there must be other ways.


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by CookieRevised on 08-15-2005 at 11:01 AM

quote:
Originally posted by lawdka0z
Must I make this point again,

IF Microsoft dont tag the whole msgplus package as unsafe, then you could just find a new adware provider and evade the bad rating!
read the other thread where you posted exactly the same....

What you say doesn't make any sense at all!!!The job of an anti-adware/spyware program is EXACTLY to decect the adware/spyware, NOT the program which supposedly contains it.

Even as it is now, Patchou could add another sponsor! And if what you say is true, then MSAS would still not detect the new sponsor at all as it simply does NOT detect the spyware/adware ITSELF.

Its job is to decect the spyware/adware, NOT to mark random programs and files which don't have anything to do with spyware/adware.

Virusscanners DO work like they should work, they decect the malicous peice of code itself, they do NOT decect the program which is infected. MSAS should work the same (just as any other anti-adware/spyware program)
RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by lawdka0z on 08-15-2005 at 11:09 AM

quote:
Originally posted by CookieRevised

which don't have anything to do with spyware/adware.


you really are an idiot, how does the adware get on the computer? THROUGH MESSENGER PLUS.


quote:
Originally posted by CookieRevised

Virusscanners DO work like they should work, they decect the malicous peice of code itself, they do NOT decect the program which is infected. MSAS should work the same (just as any other anti-adware/spyware program)



Ive seen Hacking programs intended for educational purposes added to virus scanner definition lists, does that mean the program contained a virus? NO, If your going to make a point then atleast make a decent one.
RE: RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by CookieRevised on 08-15-2005 at 12:27 PM

quote:
Originally posted by lawdka0z
quote:
Originally posted by CookieRevised
which don't have anything to do with spyware/adware.
you really are an idiot, how does the adware get on the computer? THROUGH MESSENGER PLUS.
I'm not the idiot here who needs to flame other people in a discussion, sir...

quote:
Originally posted by lawdka0z
quote:
Originally posted by CookieRevised
Virusscanners DO work like they should work, they decect the malicous peice of code itself, they do NOT decect the program which is infected. MSAS should work the same (just as any other anti-adware/spyware program)
Ive seen Hacking programs intended for educational purposes added to virus scanner definition lists, does that mean the program contained a virus? NO, If your going to make a point then atleast make a decent one.
They are added because they are BACKDOOR programs and can be used for malicious practices. Plus! isn't a hacking program at all or malicious program for that matter...

If you want to discuss something, STICK TO FACTS without twisting things around and KEEP IT IN 1 THREAD...
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by SpikedEffect on 08-15-2005 at 01:09 PM

I thought I would add my two cents here, or 2p for us British people here LOL

I can half understand Microsoft's reasons for stating Msgplus! as adware, because even though the sponsor is Optional the fact is you do get users of Mickey Soft Windows, who do not read instructions in setup wizards nor understand what they are doing.

Unfortunatly microsoft try to cater for the not so competent computer users and supply warnings to them to tell them what they are doing, which just irritates and aggrevates users who are more competent with computers.

Say for example Microsoft didn't put the warning there, they are likely to get some moron calling them saying, "I got some toolbar in internet explorer, it's all your fault for not warning me about it" just because they dun know what they are doing.

Trust me, I'm not pro Mickey Soft and I'm not anti Mickey soft, but I am just trying to keep an open mind on the issue...

Anyway that's my two cents (or my 2p)


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by dawgie on 08-15-2005 at 01:41 PM

quote:
Unfortunatly microsoft try to cater for the not so competent computer users and supply warnings to them to tell them what they are doing, which just irritates and aggrevates users who are more competent with computers.
Well unfortunately many msgplus users are not so competent and costing their mummys and daddys money to remove 'after effects'. No insult intended about the 'unfortunate' statement i made, but im just saying a lot of users below 18 do you use it more than others
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by psyko on 08-15-2005 at 01:43 PM

You all claim that MsgPlus! isn't "Spyware" and it's "Adware" but that's the whole purpose of MSAS - to remove BOTH!  So, if you don't want to get bothered, click Ignore and get over it.


Ranting by BigBean on 08-15-2005 at 02:08 PM

some peoples ignorace is truely amazing, this is an endless debate (flamewar might be a better term...), and yet after all this time, the simple message hasn't gotten through: Messenger Plus! can install adware. All this forum seems to talk about is "its optional u fukface!!1". Optional or not, it still comes with it, it can still install it, and people do install it. How does no one see that?

Adware, spyware, malware, sponsorware, crapware... whatever you want to call it, is a problem.

regardless of MsgPlus also being a religion, Patchou being your God, whatever ridiculous thing you've come up with today, it doesn't change the fact Messenger Plus! has the possibility to install it. You cannot expect 12 your noob to read 10 pages of jargon and make an imformed decision.

arguing that it is optional is paddling upstream and only makes you look more stupid. its a good thing Messenger Plus! is as good as it is, it makes up for the damage the sponsor can do to its reputation. You need to look outside this community, and see what's going on the real world.

MSAS is only doing it's job, what it was previously doing obviously wasn't helping as much as they want it to, so they've stepped up the mark. Actions have consequences. this must be the end of Patchou's cash run, perhaps he needs to realise that.


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by absorbation on 08-15-2005 at 02:10 PM

quote:
Originally posted by BigBean
some peoples ignorace is truely amazing, this is an endless debate (flamewar might be a better term...), and yet after all this time, the simple message hasn't gotten through: Messenger Plus! can install adware. All this forum seems to talk about is "its optional u fukface!!1". Optional or not, it still comes with it, it can still install it, and people do install it. How does no one see that?

Adware, spyware, malware, sponsorware, crapware... whatever you want to call it, is a problem.

regardless of MsgPlus also being a religion, Patchou being your God, whatever ridiculous thing you've come up with today, it doesn't change the fact Messenger Plus! has the possibility to install it. You cannot expect 12 your noob to read 10 pages of jargon and make an imformed decision.

arguing that it is optional is paddling upstream and only makes you look more stupid. its a good thing Messenger Plus! is as good as it is, it makes up for the damage the sponsor can do to its reputation. You need to look outside this community, and see what's going on the real world.

are you from ms anti spyware? :P you do make a good point but at the end of the day it is a false dectention you should say it's adware and optional :P
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by CookieRevised on 08-15-2005 at 02:14 PM

quote:
Originally posted by BigBean
some peoples ignorace is truely amazing, this is an endless debate (flamewar might be a better term...), and yet after all this time, the simple message hasn't gotten through: Messenger Plus! can install adware. All this forum seems to talk about is "its optional u fukface!!1". Optional or not, it still comes with it, it can still install it, and people do install it. How does no one see that?
you are missing the point of these recent discussions...

We KNOW Messenger Plus!'s installer ITSELF COULD install adware IF the user chooses to do so... But this is besides the current point, as that would be correct to detect...

The point of these recent descussions is that MSAS has gone one step further and detecting something which IS NOT there. Aka: it detects Plus! itself (msgplus.exe and the DLL's) as containing potential adware, while it never contained any adware at all. Even when you've choosen not to install the sponsor, MSAS will still give the warning.

The point is that MSAS shouldn't detect msgplus.exe, MsgPlusH.dll, MsgPlusRes.dll, etc... as malicious, but it should detect the INSTALLER as an adware containing product. If it did that, then we wouldn't had any issue with it...

quote:
Originally posted by BigBean
regardless of MsgPlus also being a religion, Patchou being your God
Messenger Plus! is far from a religion and Patchou is far from a God. If you think this way about us, then it is not us who are biased...

quote:
Originally posted by BigBean
You cannot expect 12 your noob to read 10 pages of jargon and make an imformed decision.
The 12 year old noob does NOT need to read 10 pages of jargon at all! It simply needs to read 1 sentence, or look at 1 image, or look at 1 heading in the installer to know what he/she is installing...

Don't twist around facts please...

quote:
Originally posted by BigBean
You need to look outside this community, and see what's going on the real world.
I can assure you that many of the top-helpers and most repected people of this community have a very good knowledge and sense about what's going on in the "real" world as well as in the PC world.
RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by BigBean on 08-15-2005 at 02:15 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Absorbation
are you from ms anti spyware? :P you do make a good point but at the end of the day it is a false dectention you should say it's adware and optional :P


no, I'm just pissed off with the amount of adware in this industry, and the "victims" don't know any better. saying it's adware and is optional doesn't get rid of it. that's what MSAS is supposed to do. it can still be installed.
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by absorbation on 08-15-2005 at 02:18 PM

quote:
Originally posted by BigBean
no, I'm just pissed off with the amount of adware in this industry, and the "victims" don't know any better. saying it's adware and is optional doesn't get rid of it. that's what MSAS is supposed to do. it can still be installed.

i've installed many times then i used the uninsatller, it was easy plus you never know they may want a toolbar in internet expoler :)
RE: RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Curtis on 08-15-2005 at 02:19 PM

quote:
Originally posted by lawdka0z
quote:
Originally posted by CookieRevised

which don't have anything to do with spyware/adware.


you really are an idiot, how does the adware get on the computer? THROUGH MESSENGER PLUS.


No, you really are the idiot.  Messenger Plus! does not have spyware or adware.
RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by BigBean on 08-15-2005 at 02:22 PM

quote:
Originally posted by CookieRevisedyou are missing the point of these recent discussion...

We KNOW Messenger Plus! COULD install adware IF the user chooses to do so... But this is besides the point...

The point of these recent descussions is that MSAS has gone one step further and detecting something which IS NOT there. Aka: it detects Plus! itself (msgplus.exe and the DLL's) as containing potential adware, while it never contained any adware at all. Even when you've choosen not to install the sponsor, MSAS will still give the warning.

The point is that MSAS shouldn't detect msgplus.exe, MsgPlusH.dll, MsgPlusRes.dll, etc... as malicious, but it should detect the INSTALLER as an adware containing product. If it did that, then we wouldn't had any issue with it...


Heard of a thing called "comprehension"? Read my post again if you still don't understand, or get your daddy to spell it out for you. Messenger Plus! as an application comes with adware--UNDERSTAND? Last time I scanned my PC with MSAS before this, it also listed all the registry entries in the results... they can't possibly be spywares!!1 :O

fuck, how the hell did you become MVP? step out of fanboy mode for a minute, please. don't just look at things from one angle.
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by absorbation on 08-15-2005 at 02:40 PM

they are two different programs altogther one by patchou one by c2lop :dodgy:


RE: RE: RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by CookieRevised on 08-15-2005 at 02:58 PM

quote:
Originally posted by BigBean
quote:
Originally posted by CookieRevisedyou are missing the point of these recent discussion...

We KNOW Messenger Plus! COULD install adware IF the user chooses to do so... But this is besides the point...

The point of these recent descussions is that MSAS has gone one step further and detecting something which IS NOT there. Aka: it detects Plus! itself (msgplus.exe and the DLL's) as containing potential adware, while it never contained any adware at all. Even when you've choosen not to install the sponsor, MSAS will still give the warning.

The point is that MSAS shouldn't detect msgplus.exe, MsgPlusH.dll, MsgPlusRes.dll, etc... as malicious, but it should detect the INSTALLER as an adware containing product. If it did that, then we wouldn't had any issue with it...


Heard of a thing called "comprehension"? Read my post again if you still don't understand, or get your daddy to spell it out for you. Messenger Plus! as an application comes with adware--UNDERSTAND? Last time I scanned my PC with MSAS before this, it also listed all the registry entries in the results... they can't possibly be spywares!!1 :O

fuck, how the hell did you become MVP? step out of fanboy mode for a minute, please. don't just look at things from one angle.

Plus as the *INSTALLER* comes with an EXTERNAL optional adware sponsor. Plus! as an application DOES NOT contain any adware at all! And it is exactly this which is wrongly detected atm by MSAS. And that is what these recent discussions are about...

They are NOT about the question if Messenger Plus! should come with/without a sponsor or whatever. If MSAS would detect the *INSTALLER* as containing optional adware then there would be nothing to discuss as this will be a correct detection...


And since you attack me personally or any other Messenger MVP for that matter and question our integrity: I became MVP because of my unbiased knowledge and by helping people out and by sticking to facts without twisting things around and without the need to flame/insult people, yes, also those who do not support Plus!...

I'm in the first place an MSN Messenger helper and I certainly look at things in all possible ways. If Messenger Plus! and/or Patchou does things which it doesn't suppose to be doing or if it harms users I certainly will inform the users as well as the developper. And despite what you might believe, I even recommended software to people which isn't Plus! related or is even a concurrent to Plus! if the solution calls for it...

"We" (those who are helping people out since years on this forum) are not the ones who start flaming people because they have a different opinion, instead we try to inform people how the things are. If the only thing you (and other recent people who came here to stir things up) can do in a discussion is insulting people, then please go "discussing" it on another forum.

RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by sk8michael on 08-15-2005 at 03:02 PM

WTF !!! Excuse me to those who say that Messenger Plus! is potentially dangerous for your computer, but they're wrong! I mean when you install Msg Plus!, the installer asks you if you want to install the sponsor (an adware). Of course you choose "NO", but if you choose to install the adware, just to bad for you! Even if Microsoft AntiSpyware says that msgplus.exe is a spyware (and that's not true, msgplus.exe is not a spyware itself !!!), if you have installed the sponsor, it won't change anything !!! We can say that the installer is itself a kind of adware, coz it asks you to install an adware during the installtion... But once installed, Messenger Plus! (msgplus.exe) itself is all except a spyware!!! So, I think that Microsoft Antispyware made a big mistake by qualifying Msg Plus! as a spyware !!!

Hope you'll sign the petition => here <=


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by psyko on 08-15-2005 at 05:57 PM

That petition won't do crap.  The only way to get this fixed is if Patchou does it himself.  And I mean, what the hell is the problem?  You want MSAS to go easy on stuff that could potentially work the same way as Plus! (the installer, the hooks, etc.), but yet slip by? - Then you'd be blaming MSAS!  You can't have your cake and eat it too!  Not everyone may be as knowledgable as us to know it isn't or not to click Next Next etc..., but come on!  Just click Ignore for hell's sake!!!!!!


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by EvilSeph on 08-15-2005 at 06:02 PM

From tests, ignore doesn't do much. Infact, it's crippled Messenger Plus! sometimes.


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Lou on 08-15-2005 at 06:06 PM

quote:
Originally posted by lawdka0z
    quote:Originally posted by CookieRevised

    which don't have anything to do with spyware/adware.



you really are an idiot, how does the adware get on the computer? THROUGH MESSENGER PLUS.

if youve got such a problem with it, shut up, and Dont install it.

I hope messenger plus! is not going to go down by reputation because of people like you.
RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Curtis on 08-15-2005 at 06:27 PM

Messenger Plus won't go down, its the best add-on for MSN Messenger.  At least in my opinion it is.


RE: MS AntiSpyware Now Blocks Messenger Plus! by Patchou on 08-15-2005 at 07:12 PM

Enough of yelling for one day, thread closed. You want me to do something about it? I will, but it won't be whatever anyone like you is thinking right now, I can promise that, I'm tired of the BS.