This is the first time an episode of Lost has made me want to actually discuss it. The episode I'm talking about is the one shown this week on American TV:

3x19 - After abandoning the Others, Locke takes Sawyer on a trek through the jungle to help him eliminate a common enemy. Meanwhile, back at the beach, the parachutist Naomi has crucial information about flight 815.

So really, now they're basically telling us that everyone on that island is dead and it's some form of afterlife? I remember reading a thread a long while back contemplating what might really be going on and someone said that perhaps they're all dead. I didn't think they'd have actually done that, because it would render everything that's happened there pointless, because, well, they're all DEAD.

Of course, maybe they're not dead. Maybe it's just a way of raising more questions. But I doubt it, after all, certain things seem to make sense now. Like why Locke can walk, why people are suddenly fertile when they're on the island, why... well, everything. But if they're actually dead, then what happens if they 'die' when they're dead?

Oh well, at least Lost is progressing. I was getting a bit annoyed by how slowly it was going.

quote:

---

Originally posted by segosa
Of course, maybe they're not dead. Maybe it's just a way of raising more questions.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by segosa
...certain things seem to make sense now. Like ... why people are suddenly fertile when they're on the island...

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by segosa
Oh well, at least Lost is progressing.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Volv

quote:

---

Originally posted by segosa
...certain things seem to make sense now. Like ... why people are suddenly fertile when they're on the island...

---

I don't understand how being dead makes you fertile, if anything it would make you infertile as it can't be possible to give birth to a living baby in the afterlife can it?

---

its a giant red herring if you ask me

o.0   people still watch that?

quote:

---

Originally posted by ICD
o.0   people still watch that?

---

I'm not sure. I read somewhere that they're not dead - the producers of the show said it themselves.

I had a theory about the bodies being recovered as some sort of cover-up, but then, they'dve just killed everyone on the crash if that was the case.

They're making 7 series, so it's only like 3 and a half years till we find out.

They are not dead, the idea of them being dead was brought up as a theory by the fans during series one, and was debunked by the creators.

Cooper probably thought that's what was going on, he says he was in a car crash, and the next thing he knew, he was on an Island. Just in the same way that everyone was knocked out when they crashed on the plane, the way that Juliette had to be knocked out to get to the Island, Naomi was unconcious when they found her, Desmond got knocked out and his first memory was being dragged to the hatch by Kelvin.

They claim that the plane wreckage was found, but DHARMA seems to be intent on keeping the Island a secret, so with all their money, it wouldn't be too hard to put a plane 4 miles underwater where they can't bring it to the surface of the water and only robotos can go and see it. So maybe it was just a way to stop the search for the survivors to uncover the island.

Also, Penny may have known the coordinates because she is the daughter of the owner of Widmore Industries, the same company who provided the pregnancy tests, and sponsored Henry Gale's balloon ride, so Widmore is obviously involved in some way, shape, or form.

* Chris4 misses Lost

* Chris4 shoots Virgin Media for not making a deal with Sky to keep Sky One, etc.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Damokun
I thought it had only just been renewed for a fourth? O.o

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Damokun

quote:

---

Originally posted by andrewdodd13
They're making 7 series, so it's only like 3 and a half years till we find out.

---

I thought it had only just been renewed for a fourth? O.o

---

I think the producers clearly said some time ago that they ARE NOT dead.

Well..Locke is my favorite character.

He is going to join the others but just to get what he wants, i dont believe he will really start to make part of them.

He will probably work alone to achieve whichever objective he wants to achieve.

I think Penny is a cool character, she has money and ambition, with that she can do anything. But I still want to find out how the woman knows Penny.

I want to know where all the copies of that picture came from, it was a polaroid that took the photo, and Desmond kept it, so where did Penny get the same photo to give to Naomi?

I'm curious how the russian guy came back to life, why the oracle knew that priest were desmond was and why didn't Naomi mention Michael or Walt, are they hiding?
Good to know though that we're going to know more about the DHARMA initiative.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Lourix
I think Penny is a cool character, she has money and ambition, with that she can do anything. But I still want to find out how the woman knows Penny.

---

Lost wont last 7 seasons. Everyone will get sick of it by then. People hate itwhen shows drag on for ages! 7 seasons is to long!

They announced today there will be two more seasons . All I can say is thank goodness, the writers can start tieing up all the loose ends. Remember everything has its day and it's best to end something on a high.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Discrate
Lost wont last 7 seasons. Everyone will get sick of it by then. People hate itwhen shows drag on for ages! 7 seasons is to long!

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by segosa
So really, now they're basically telling us that everyone on that island is dead and it's some form of afterlife? I remember reading a thread a long while back contemplating what might really be going on and someone said that perhaps they're all dead. I didn't think they'd have actually done that, because it would render everything that's happened there pointless, because, well, they're all DEAD.

---

After all the shit that they have come up with, of which would be hard to explain i actually wouldn't be surprised if the outcome was, that it really is hell.
But i also doubt it, it was just another episode in a pointless series. they drag it on far too much.

Lost will finish up in 2009.

[Spoiler]


OMG...I'm shocked, what the hell was that (3x20)?
I think Jacob doesn't like Ben very much...
And i'm not so sure about "good guys" any more.

theyre the hostiles!!

someone caputred pictures of jacob.. he flashed up like once or twice so hes not a fake parlour trick

erm, why locke, hes one of the ost interesting characters!?

Just noticed:



JACOB is LOCKE
It really seems

Jacob will help Locke =P

oooooooooooo good spot, heard about the theories but that picture is just so similar

thanks

I just saw 3x17 (yes, Sweden is slow!), and I found out something intresting. You know the high-tech mobile phone they found from the girl with the parachute?
If you pause and zooms in on it, there's a world map, and green circles pointing on a specific location. When I saw this, I find the coordinates for the point, they are: 42, 108, 32, 16 or something like that, can't remember exactly.
Offtopic:
I got to sleep, clock is 1.08.

Lost is getting really good, the amount of symbology and parallels with other books and things are amazing.

I also think that Locke isn't dead because he was shot where his kidney would've been, but obviously the kidney is not there anymore.

Or maybe, Eko's "you're next" prophecy was true; Nikki, Paulo, Desmond, Lock and Sayid were all around Eko, and so far 2 have definatly died, one maybe has died, and there is a massive showdown between the Losties and the Hostiles, so two more fatalities aren't beyond the realms of possibility.

I've just watched 3x20...
do you really think they are dead or we are just supposed to belive it?

quote:

---

Originally posted by Rik
JACOB is LOCKE
It really seems

Jacob will help Locke =P

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by linx05
Lost will finish up in 2009.

---

For ppl who watched 3x20:
Do you think Annie is Rousseau?
If yes, is Ben Alex's real father?

Rousseau looks older than Ben and Annie looks younger, but that's a possibility, dont you think?

quote:

---

Originally posted by Chancer
For ppl who watched 3x20:
Do you think Annie is Rousseau?
If yes, is Ben Alex's real father?

Rousseau looks older than Ben and Annie looks younger, but that's a possibility, dont you think?

---

Who is Ms. Hawkings?

YESS!!! LOCKE ISNT DEAD!!!!

..reportedly


he gets shot in the stomach, but ben sed in an interview, he has a medical condtion in his favour, because of something he lost a long time ago

NOT HAVING A KIDNEY MEANS NO INTERNAL BLEEDING OR WHATEVER WOOOO ^

SPoiler ^^^

quote:

---

Originally posted by Chancer
Who is Ms. Hawkings?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by M73A
he gets shot in the stomach, but ben sed in an interview, he has a medical condtion in his favour, because of something he lost a long time ago

---

I know it says spoilers in the subject, but we aren't talking about episodes that haven't aired

Yeah i read a preview for an upcoming ep and it said someone you thought was dead returns.
I thought that whole episode was stupid, the guy you cant see i mean.. who are these writers they just keep making this more and more ridiculous

WOOWWWWW

poor charlie even though i really want him to make it, i can't see it happening :'-(

if anyone has read the info about the finale.. WOW SHOCKER.. if not, you're in for a good one if its correct


was that the saddest episode ever or what!

quote:

---

Originally posted by Pyroteq
Yeah i read a preview for an upcoming ep and it said someone you thought was dead returns.
I thought that whole episode was stupid, the guy you cant see i mean.. who are these writers they just keep making this more and more ridiculous

---