I made an example of the suggested features:
BlahWriter
Posting Freak
Posts: 1159
Rating: 815
Comments: 33
Age: 16, sex:
Joined: Feb 2003
Status: Offline
* Titles are still shown, but they refer to the amount of posts like "lurker", "regular poster", "posting freak", not to things like "newbie", "respected", "elite". Although "admin", "mod" is still shown afcourse
* Postcount is also shown (but with the other fields, this will have a meaning now. So, spammers, going for the highest postcount isn't so smart anymore)
* Rating: both the new mybb rating AND the comment-rating is shown
I think we agree on that, no? (as I've seen no objectives about that lately)...
But indeed the questions now are: who? when? why? what? etc...
I posted some points/remarks about this before. To make things easier I think we should vote/discuss 1 point at the time, otherwise it is pure chaos....
To start off:
who can vote (for the rating-system)?
* Elite's and up
* Users (limited by registration date {+7days}, postcount {+20} and reputation {must be at least positive}) <= I vote for this (figures are just a suggestion)
* Everybody
(my 2$)