Check that you have checked the box in Plus! > Preferences > Contact List > Custom Contact Names > Use custom contact names while chatting. To make it "gray-checked" you have to enable the Display custom contact names box, enable the other one, and then disable the first one.
Hope this helps
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f1950/f195095cc01d3407ef44b2ba819041ebb7f4fb87" alt=":P"