quote:
Originally posted by saralk
firstly - I don't think you should be able to vote on someone who's post count is below 100, the main reason is that if they are not allowed to vote for anyone because they dont have enough posts, we shouldnt be allowed to vote for them.
I don't agree. The reason why users with less than 100 posts can't vote is that they might abuse the system by making useless accounts just for voting. There is no similar reason for stopping users who
do have 100+ posts from voting for users with less. I believe the current rule is fair, because you earn the privilege to vote by posting.
quote:
Also it can take a while for people to get used to the way the forum works, so if they start out as a spammer, and get a really low reputation it may scare them off
Or help them to realize and correct their mistakes! I don't think newbies will get negative votes just for being newbies. They have to actually do something stupid that gets them noticed.
quote:
secondly - Since the feedback page looks like the eBay page, then why not have a indicator showing how many votes are positive.
What do you mean? There are already counts of how many votes are positive/neutral/negative...
quote:
Also a chance for members to reply about votes.
In other words, a place dedicated to arguments. I dunno about that...
/ 
