Well.. haven't played GTA 4 myself. I believe there isn't an official PC version yet or at least I didn't see one yet
So I can't really comment on that.
God of War 2 for PS2 was win. Too bad it wasn't multi-platform. It sure does take the #1 spot for PS2 games (so say an online thingo. I haven't played more than 50 ps2 games but I still think its by far the best I've played in all respects. Gameplay, videos, storyline etc)
/ 
