Shoutbox

Lily might just have nothing to do with the book at all though. There was never anything really in the end to prove that she did.

Except for the numerous times Slughorn mentioned her.

quote:

---

Originally posted by ajd
Lily might just have nothing to do with the book at all though. There was never anything really in the end to prove that she did.

---

Yeah, we are probably over thinking this

I still stick by my theory that she had something to do with Snape or the Half-Blood Prince

Yup, even though they are the same thing

quote:

---

Originally posted by Jimcando
I still stick by my theory that she had something to do with Snape or the Half-Blood Prince

---

Snape is the half-blood prince

LOL, Does anyone have any other thoughts on R.A.B besides Regulas

It could be Regulas actually although I hadn't thought of it before. It might just be someone who hasn't been in the books before.
What did the note say again? I can't be bothered to get the book and I'm very busy with coursework but you're all distracting me!!!

OK, I know Snape is the Half-Blood Prince. I just meant that she had something to do with the book as well.

I did a very quick Google search and here are some theories on the first page I found:
Regulas Black had a locket in his house which Mundungus could of stolen...more here
Another theory, RAB might never of made it back to the shore of the lake and might be floating in the water!
Also, Amelia Bones...she could have a secret first name

See here

Yeh i read the one about the locket "which could not be opened" on Muggle Net. Seems the most probably theory but seems too easy to figure out