|  Attachments | 
| Author: | 
Message: | 
KeyStorm 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
Inn-sewer-ants-pollie-sea
  
Posts: 2156 Reputation: 45 
39 /   / – 
Joined: Jan 2003 
 | 
 RE: Attachments
Would you understand this? 
[*Name of the attachment]  ![[Image: attachment.php?tid=21089&pid=198724]](http://shoutbox.menthix.net/attachment.php?tid=21089&pid=198724)  
 
  Attachment: _self_blank.gif (176 bytes) 
This file has been downloaded 409 time(s). 
 This post was edited on 02-07-2004 at 03:11 PM by KeyStorm.
 |   
 | 
| 02-07-2004 02:56 PM | 
 | 
  | 
Choli 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
Choli
  
Posts: 4714 Reputation: 42 
44 /   /   
Joined: Jan 2003 
 | 
 RE: Attachments
quote: Originally posted by KeyStorm 
Would you understand this? 
 
[link to the attachment] ![[Image: attachment.php?tid=21089&pid=198724]](http://shoutbox.menthix.net/attachment.php?tid=21089&pid=198724) 
  and where you put [link to the attachment] there would be the name of the file, wouldn't it? well, in that case it could be a possible solution
 quote: Originally posted by fluffy_lobster 
*coughserverloadcough*
  *cough*  *cough*this is not t&t*cough*  
 |   
 | 
| 02-07-2004 03:06 PM | 
 | 
  | 
Guido 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
Design is Safety
  
Posts: 4566 Reputation: 50 
38 /   /   
Joined: Dec 2002 
 | 
 RE: RE: Attachments
quote: Originally posted by CookieRevised 
quote: Originally posted by Choli 
in that case it should open in the same page. WDZ should make the script distinguish both cases (zip, rar, exe, ... -> the same page; gif, bmp, png, jpg, doc, txt, html, ... -> _blank)
  doc? .DOC's don't open inline in a browser by default, unless you have a plugin or something...
  Yes -- a plugin called... Microsoft Word   
quote: Another big drawback: when you choose to download (save it) something, you'll open a new browser window/tab which will be empty. I find this very annoying as you have to close all those empty windows afterwards...
  As said above, at least IE closes the new window if it has no content.
 quote: Originally posted by fluffy_lobster 
*coughserverloadcough*
  Nothing to do with server load    
 |   
 | 
| 02-07-2004 08:07 PM | 
 | 
  | 
fluffy_lobster 
Veteran Member 
     
  
  
Posts: -2
  
Posts: 1390 Reputation: 23 
37 /   /   
Joined: Nov 2002 
 | 
 RE: Attachments
*sigh* i was referring to choli's suggestion that there be an option in the user cp.  It seems a bit unnecessary to add all that into the database just for the sake of choosing. 
I say just make it launch in _blank like the rest of the links in postbit.
 Or maybe have it open a page with the mybb template with an iframe in the middle that has the url of the relevant attachment.php?  That way it would show images/text on the page and pop up other miscellaneous downloads, and you wouldn't forget your were in mybb.  Just thought of that... just an idea   
I prefer _blank though  
 |   
 | 
| 02-07-2004 08:35 PM | 
 | 
  | 
Guido 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
Design is Safety
  
Posts: 4566 Reputation: 50 
38 /   /   
Joined: Dec 2002 
 | 
 RE: Attachments
quote: Originally posted by fluffy_lobster 
*sigh* i was referring to choli's suggestion that there be an option in the user cp.
  Sorry   
(btw was it deleted?)
 quote: I prefer _blank though
  Same here   
 
 |   
 | 
| 02-08-2004 12:25 AM | 
 | 
  | 
CookieRevised 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
 
Posts: 15494 Reputation: 173 
– /   /   
Joined: Jul 2003
 
Status: Away
 
 | 
 RE: RE: RE: Attachments
quote: Originally posted by Guido 
Yes -- a plugin called... Microsoft Word  
  Sorry, no... not all browsers are configured to do that... it is optional/to-be-set-up.
 quote: Originally posted by Guido 
...at least IE closes the new window if it has no content.
  Again, not everybody uses IE...
 
If such things "have" to change then consider EVERY browser. I'm sorry, but this is what makes bad homepages etc; assuming everybody uses the same software... while instead you should make it "compatible" for every software (or as much as you can), don't make it look nice for some particular browser.... 
(^^ not meant personaly Guido   )
 
And all this, just because we are too lazy to use the (right-click,middle-click, whatever) feature of our browser called "open link in a new window"?????    
 This post was edited on 02-08-2004 at 01:13 AM by CookieRevised.
.-= A 'frrrrrrrituurrr' for Wacky =-.  
 |   
 | 
| 02-08-2004 01:09 AM | 
 | 
  | 
KeyStorm 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
Inn-sewer-ants-pollie-sea
  
Posts: 2156 Reputation: 45 
39 /   / – 
Joined: Jan 2003 
 | 
 RE: Attachments
 This post was edited on 02-08-2004 at 01:50 AM by KeyStorm.
 |   
 | 
| 02-08-2004 01:43 AM | 
 | 
  | 
CookieRevised 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
 
Posts: 15494 Reputation: 173 
– /   /   
Joined: Jul 2003
 
Status: Away
 
 | 
 RE: Attachments
 
1) I bet someone would come up with those figures 
2) "overall" standard?  
3) we're not talking about HTML implementation, but about the userinterface of browsers. 
4) put a big nice page on the first page of the forums: "made for MSIE"....   
5) I'm saying: make something for a as much wide userbase as you can. eg: Patchou could decide to make plus! only work on XP... if you make something for the big public, then consider all the different sofware uses... 
6) Don't let this evolve into "which browser is the best"... 
7) this is going off-topic 
8) The main thing is: Dont' be lazy and right-click/middle-click before you choose to "view" an attachment; That's the way normal links work in general; In this case the saying "if it isn't broke, don't fix it" comes in my mind...  
 This post was edited on 02-08-2004 at 01:56 AM by CookieRevised.
.-= A 'frrrrrrrituurrr' for Wacky =-.  
 |   
 | 
| 02-08-2004 01:55 AM | 
 | 
  | 
KeyStorm 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
Inn-sewer-ants-pollie-sea
  
Posts: 2156 Reputation: 45 
39 /   / – 
Joined: Jan 2003 
 | 
 RE: Attachments
1) I'm the one   
2) I meant the "most accepted as" (sorry for my English) 
3) I agree 
4) oh, come on... I didn't mean that 
5) I'm talking about the  most used. I don't know if others behave in that way,.I'm talking about my own experience with MSIE and the experience of the 95% of users 
6) noway!  
7) rrrright   
8) YES, that's what I'm saying (read some posts above), but I suggested a  friendly solution for everyone  
 |   
 | 
| 02-08-2004 02:05 AM | 
 | 
  | 
Guido 
Elite Member 
     
  
  
Design is Safety
  
Posts: 4566 Reputation: 50 
38 /   /   
Joined: Dec 2002 
 | 
 RE: Attachments
Blah, CookieRevised, cookies are supported by IE as well, don't make it personal   
quote: Originally posted by CookieRevised 
Originally posted by Guido 
...at least IE closes the new window if it has no content. 
 
Again, not everybody uses IE...
  If you're going against IE, at least only do it where other browsers are better (i.e.: almost everything else). But if 1~10% of the visitors have a browser with a feature that is inferior to the rest (in this case, other browsers leave an empty window when downloading in a new page) I don't think that's big of an issue.
 
So, back to the topic.   
Options: 
a) leave it as it is. 
b) make everything open in _blank.
 
I vote for B.
  
 |   
 | 
| 02-08-2004 03:29 AM | 
 | 
  | 
| 
Pages: (4): 
« First
 
«
 
 1
 2
 [ 3 ]
 4
 
»
 
Last »
 | 
| 
 |