Here we can discuss the ending of Harry Potter.



Do not read this thread if you haven't finished it.  Or it will ruin it!

http://www.fazed.org/video/view/?filename=pottercrash.wmv


lol

I think it was a good ending. Very climaxed.
Have to wait ~2yrs for next one, although the ending has been already written.
I think Ginny and Harry should've stayed together.

Yeah I wished they would have stayed together two.  It is going to be weird in the next book when they are not going to hogwarts.  When I read that dumbledore died I kept on telling myself snape faked it.  Until I like got to the Burial part, and I still couldn't believe he was dead

Lol, i think snape will die in 7. and i think rowling will kill a few more characters.

I never liked Snape but I always thought that he was on the Good guys side...Stupid Snape

I was hoping to see a resume.. :/

I hate reading so could you tell what happens?

Yeh you would think that dumbeldores decision was the best. I new harry/dumbledore was going to die when harry and ron were in the Burrow (at xmas) and harry told ron about the "unbreakable vow" and ron told him that you would die if you didnt fulfil it.

I want to read the chapter about Bill and Fleur's wedding, i think that would be funny.

It's stranger i think j.k rowling like's killing things in her books e.g:
book 1: the one who voldemort was controlling dies,
book 2: The snake dies
book 3: can't remember but i no somethin dies
book 4: cedric dies
book 5: siruis
book 6: dumbledore

book 1: quirell
book 3: crouch (one in azkaban)
book 5: siruis + garden keeper in riddle house
book 6: dumbledore + death eater

Yeh and the reason for killing people close to Harry Rowling said:
"It is more satisfying I think for the reader if the hero has to go on alone and to give him too much support makes his job too easy, sorry."

Well if no one died then Voldermorte woulnd't be a very thrilling badguy would he

true. i guess most of book 7 will be about him finding the rest of teh Horcuxes, probably assuming that he doesnt go back to Hogwarts.

*cough*

book 1: Lily and James Potter, Quirell.
Book 2: no-one that I can think of.
book 3: Barty Crouch
book 4: Cedric, the three people in the huge house. (forgotten the names. o.o) and we are told of people who have died previously.
book 5: Sirius ()
book 6: Dumbledore () and a death eater, and in the memories, people are killed, for example: Morfin.

you all know me and my crazy theories. I think Snape is still a good guy.

We don't know why Dumbledore trusted Snape so much, in the face of so much stuff, Dumbledore never once doubted Snape's excuse for why he told Voldy about the prophecy.

My theory is that the potion itself was the Horcrux they were looking for, and so Dumbledore told Snape to kill him, thus destroying the Horcrux. He used occulumency and legemillins (sp?) to communicate with Snape about this, but because he was so ill he was confused and was saying what Snape was saying to him. "no, don't make me do it", i think that saying "KILL ME" at the end was dumbledore giving the final word to snape.

I also think that Harry is the final Horcrux, so he will have to kill voldermort (probably at the department of mysteries) and then will fall through the veil in order to finish voldermort off once and for all.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Tasha
book 1: Lily and James Potter, Quirell.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by paperless
I was hoping to see a resume.. :/

I hate reading so could you tell what happens?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Saralk

you all know me and my crazy theories. I think Snape is still a good guy.

We don't know why Dumbledore trusted Snape so much, in the face of so much stuff, Dumbledore never once doubted Snape's excuse for why he told Voldy about the prophecy.

My theory is that the potion itself was the Horcrux they were looking for, and so Dumbledore told Snape to kill him, thus destroying the Horcrux. He used occulumency and legemillins (sp?) to communicate with Snape about this, but because he was so ill he was confused and was saying what Snape was saying to him. "no, don't make me do it", i think that saying "KILL ME" at the end was dumbledore giving the final word to snape.

I also think that Harry is the final Horcrux, so he will have to kill voldermort (probably at the department of mysteries) and then will fall through the veil in order to finish voldermort off once and for all.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by saralk
My theory is that the potion itself was the Horcrux they were looking for, and so Dumbledore told Snape to kill him, thus destroying the Horcrux. He used occulumency and legemillins (sp?) to communicate with Snape about this, but because he was so ill he was confused and was saying what Snape was saying to him. "no, don't make me do it", i think that saying "KILL ME" at the end was dumbledore giving the final word to snape.

I also think that Harry is the final Horcrux, so he will have to kill voldermort (probably at the department of mysteries) and then will fall through the veil in order to finish voldermort off once and for all.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by paperless
I was hoping to see a resume.. :/
I hate reading so could you tell what happens?

---

I doubt it will be out next year but I hope it is.

I might read book 5 again, it's the only one I haven't read 100 times and I forgot some of the stuff which happened which was quite important in book 6.

I think in book 7, Harry will either die fighting Voldemort (killing him first, of course! ) or become an Auror.

Harry better not die  It says one of them can survive if the other one doesn't so if Harry kills him first then there is no problem with him living

quote:

---

Originally posted by saralk
We don't know why Dumbledore trusted Snape so much, in the face of so much stuff, Dumbledore never once doubted Snape's excuse for why he told Voldy about the prophecy.

---

Who do you lot think is R.A.B ?
I think its Regulas Black.

JK Rowling said something big would be revealed in book 6 about Lily, nothing besides "she was great at potions" is revealed.

I think Snape is still a bad guy because Dumbledore did not tell him to kill him before the unbreakable vow.

Maybe Harry will survive in the last book, but someone close to him will die once again.

Harry may return to Hogwarts for some reason or another where we will know the new defence against dark arts teacher.

There is a member of the Order of the Phoenix which will play a big role in book 7. He has been introduced but not very highly.

Snape and Malfoy i think both die.

quote:

---

Originally posted by hmaster5
Snape and Malfoy i think both die.

---

What are people's opinions on whether Malfoy is a death eater or not? It didn't actually say.

I think Malfoy is a death eater.  Even though I don't think he can handle it.

I think Lily Potter had something to do with the Half-Blood Prince.
Hermione kept saying it could of been a girl, the handwriting was supposedly girly and the Potions teacher (forgot the name) kept saying Harry had the same techniques as his Mother.
Perhaps Lily Potter and Snape 'got it on' and she helped him in Potions

It would explain why Snape and James hated each other so much :/

Although it's not very likely

quote:

---

Originally posted by Jimcando
Perhaps Lily Potter and Snape 'got it on' and she helped him in Potions

---

yeh he is, or more importanty was made to be for Lucius's stupid mistakes.

Bellatrix and Pettigrew didnt do much.

Lily defended Snape, if you remember in the Pensieve. Maybe Snape was in love with her and he used to tell her his secrets. Thats why he hated James.

And Harrys mum kept sticking up for Snape.

Lily might just have nothing to do with the book at all though. There was never anything really in the end to prove that she did.

Except for the numerous times Slughorn mentioned her.

quote:

---

Originally posted by ajd
Lily might just have nothing to do with the book at all though. There was never anything really in the end to prove that she did.

---

I still stick by my theory that she had something to do with Snape or the Half-Blood Prince

Yup, even though they are the same thing

quote:

---

Originally posted by Jimcando
I still stick by my theory that she had something to do with Snape or the Half-Blood Prince

---

LOL, Does anyone have any other thoughts on R.A.B besides Regulas

It could be Regulas actually although I hadn't thought of it before. It might just be someone who hasn't been in the books before.
What did the note say again? I can't be bothered to get the book and I'm very busy with coursework but you're all distracting me!!!

OK, I know Snape is the Half-Blood Prince. I just meant that she had something to do with the book as well.

I did a very quick Google search and here are some theories on the first page I found:
Regulas Black had a locket in his house which Mundungus could of stolen...more here
Another theory, RAB might never of made it back to the shore of the lake and might be floating in the water!
Also, Amelia Bones...she could have a secret first name

See here

Yeh i read the one about the locket "which could not be opened" on Muggle Net. Seems the most probably theory but seems too easy to figure out

quote:

---

Originally posted by Jimcando

Also, Amelia Bones...she could have a secret first name

---

Its possible. Maybe JKR has strategicly placed it all there and she will just introduce a new character called RAB

Let's face it. Harry's life is f***ed. My prediction about the next book is that it's going to be a wild goose chase ending up with a big battle between Harry and Voldy. And I think that Harry's going to wind up dead.

But logically, this IS the last book, so Voldy too has to die as JK wont leave such a big ending with voldy remaining alive.

I also think Dumbledore will come back in some way. Perhaps as a ghost (although unlikely) or somehow contact Harry in one of his very magical ways

quote:

---

Originally posted by hmaster5
But logically, this IS the last book, so Voldy too has to die.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Jimcando
I also think Dumbledore will come back in some way. Perhaps as a ghost (although unlikely) or somehow contact Harry in one of his very magical ways

---

He does have a gold framed one. It says so.

Dumbledore also said the prophecy may or may not be true. Imagine if Harry didnt know about the prophecy. Do all prophecys come true?

The prophecy really just egged Harry on. He really just wants Voldy dead for revenge.

btw R.A.B's Note:

quote:

---

To the Dark Lord
I know I will be dead long before you read this but I want you to know that it was I who discovered your secret.
I have stolen the real Horcrux and intend to destroy it as soon as I can.
I face death in the hope that when you meet your match, you will be mortal once more.
R.A.B.

---

R.A.B is Really Annoying Bird-man

quote:

---

I also think that Harry is the final Horcrux, so he will have to kill voldermort (probably at the department of mysteries) and then will fall through the veil in order to finish voldermort off once and for all.

---

Yeah ... <3 dumbeldore ....
* John Anderton slaps Snape around a bit with a large trout.
And btw .... i kiiled snape when i heard

Why did he have to do that.
And why doesnt draco die .... die snape and draco die.
And voldemort too but thats obvious that id say that.

quote:

---

Originally posted by The Don
R.A.B is Really Annoying Bird-man

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Freaky Guy
impossible....voldy splitted his sould before he went off to kill harry....he couldnt do the horcrux after his body was killed!


okay, i think snapes on the good side....the killing of dumbledore was probabl preplanned...dumbledore knw he was to die..he mentions several times bout old age, maybe thats wat dumbledore and snape were arguiing about....maybe snape didnt want to kill DD. i think that DD asked him to kill so that he doesnt break the unbreakable vow...so that snape didnt die and voldy will then be surely convinced that snapes on his side.

also, snape had so many occasions to kill harry, but he always put off that even in front of other death eaters that harry was to be reserved for voldy, but in the previous books, it was clear voldemort wanted harry dead whoever killed him.

anyway, snape is extremly powerful, his potion books proves it. DD always says death is not the worst thing....i think he must have had very important reasons for getting himself killed. i also think that dumbledore was pleading to snape to kill him just before he died.

just a thought....tel me wat do u think!
also, when harry calls snape a coward, he stops to deny this, cos killing dd would have taken a lot of guts

---

* John Anderton makes Joanne Kathleene Rowling his new best friend

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Anderton
And couldnt dd have a horcrux thingy

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Anderton
And i think dd isnt gone as next year there will be a new 'hm' for hogwarts (assuming the school is open cause else it'll be dodgy or really exciting ) (How do you make a hp book with out all that school stuff ..... the book will be really full of lotsa content then but its unlikely )
DD isnt gone imo ..... he is said to be one of the greatest wizards of his / all tim

---

after bill and fleurs wedding, where somethign could happen

This brings up another question: Will book 7 have "Year 7" on the side of the book like the rest of the books, and if so, What does it mean?

i think he will go back to hogwarts to look for the Gryfindor/Ravenclaw Horcrux

quote:

---

Originally posted by hmaster5
Dumbledore also said the prophecy may or may not be true. Imagine if Harry didnt know about the prophecy. Do all prophecys come true?

The prophecy really just egged Harry on. He really just wants Voldy dead for revenge.

---

Personally I don't think Dumbledore will be coming back. It would be a bit of a poor ending if he somehow came back to life. Might as well just bring everyone back to life, like Harry's parents. Bit of a cop out really

I'm not so convinced that Sirius Black is dead to be honest. His "death" was a bit vague I think - I expect him to make an appearance in book 7.

Finally I am convinced that Snape isn't a bad guy. It would make good book writing for JK Rowling to try to make everyone believe that Snape was a bad guy all along, but in actual fact it turns out that he is actually good. Dumbledore never stated why he trusted Snape so absolutely, but I think he was right. Dumbledore was one of the wisest and greatest wizards ever - he wouldn't make a mistake as big as that

quote:

---

he wouldn't make a mistake as big as that 

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by FrozernFire
you have to kill to make a horcrux, but like you said, you have not read the book

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Anderton

quote:

---

Originally posted by FrozernFire
you have to kill to make a horcrux, but like you said, you have not read the book

---

Oh yeah .... i heard that too
Couldnt dd have killed someone evil for it
<3 dd R.I.P (i guess )

Imo if there is school next year then the hm has to be mrs. mcgonagal

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Freaky Guy
it is DARK ARTS...its sooo dark that it has no mention even in the hogwarts library......dd couldnt have learned such dark magic...or even if he did knw, he wouldnt use it!

---

maybe....but i seriously doubt dd having a horcrux...slughorn didnt even wanted dd to knw he knw bout it!!!

quote:

---

Originally posted by Jeronimo
Dumbledore was one of the wisest and greatest wizards ever - he wouldn't make a mistake as big as that

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Anderton
Imo if there is school next year then the hm has to be mrs. mcgonagal

---

ok, i only have 2 questions about the book.

1. who is R.A.B, if it was regulus black, isnt he head? if so when where is harry going to find the horcrux?

2. Now that Dumbledore's portrait is in the headmasters office, could harry talk to him, just like he used ot be able to, will he be the same? That would be really good cos then harry wouldnt be totally alone. I hope so

I gotta say that Saralk's predictions that he wrote for MuggleNet are really good and most of it came true.

* ipab applauds Saralk for his deductions and JKR for her wit.

I really enjoyed the book, although I don't really appreciate not having a proper closure, she left herself room for a sequel, which we all know is coming, so wuts the point (except $_$)

quote:

---

Originally posted by hmaster5
She already took over the post at the end of HBP

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Karun's Journal .... link mentioned above

Redeeming Dumbledore's Death


Spoiler Warning! As if the title of this web site wasn't warning enough for most people...

So, Dumbledore is dead. Why? There are two, erm, "Points of View" regarding this. One is Harry's, which the book, being focussed as a camera hovering slightly above Harry's head, obviously takes, and, the second is the more rational point of view, which I will discuss here.

In Book 5, Mr. Potter completed his ultimate transformation - he became a painful git. And so, this solidified the fact that, for me, the main hero of the stories became Dumbledore instead of the first two words of the book's title. The notion of Dumbledore's extremely perceptive and receptive brain has been built up with each successive HP title and this book adds to it. I will now go on to explain why I think Dumbledore died of his own free will and did not, as it appears, beg for mercy from S. Snape.

A. P. W. B. Dumbledore is not stupid. This is the salient point throughout my theory and I've believed in this fact since even before the new millennium began. He wouldn't have trusted S. Snape if he didn't have the cold, hard facts on him. Remember how he knew all about Tom Riddle when he came seeking a job at Hogwarts?

Dumbledore knew about the Unforgivable Vow that bound Snape and N. Malfoy. He might have known about this from Snape beforehand and he might have also known what Malfoy intended to do.
Hagrid caught Snape and Dumbledore quarreling at the edge of the forest, and Dumbledore was trying to impress upon Snape, the fact, that he had to do whatever he was told. Also note that they were "quarreling" and not merely talking or discussing as is usually Dumbledore's fashion. This implies that the topic of conversation must be something really big and Dumbledore was forcing Snape to do something that Snape really didn't want to. It could just not be as trivial as investigating Malfoy.
When Potter and Dumbledore returned from the cave, Dumbledore repeatedly asked for Severus Snape and no one else. McGongall and Hagrid were equally trustworthy but he insisted on Snape. Think "Why?".
Also note that, throughout the Cave adventure, Dumbledore kept mentioning how his life was no longer important and that it was Harry who needed to live, not him.
Dumbledore didn't want Draco Malfoy to become a killer. In him, he saw a younger S. Snape and he didn't want him to go over to the Dark side. For this reason, he prevented Draco from killing which would - please excuse me for using Star Wars lingo - complete his transition to the Dark side. He also made sure to ask Malfoy whether any one had been killed and engaged him in conversation until the other Death Eaters had arrived.
When Snape came up to the Astronomy tower, he walked up determinedly. When he got near, his face, as it is mentioned, was filled with hatred. Also, Dumbledore said, in a pleading voice, "... Severus... please...". I just cannot believe that Dumbledore would ever beg for mercy for his life because he was simply unafraid of death. "Death is but the next great adventure", he said to Harry in Harry's first year.
Let's review the information in the light that I shed on it. Dumbledore knew about the Vow and he discussed this with Snape. The plan that Dumbledore chalked out included his own death, and Snape, loyal to Dumbledore, quarreled with him at the edge of the forest because he did not want to kill Dumbledore. Whilst in the cave, Dumbledore impresses upon young Potter about how his own life is no longer important. Dumbledore sends only for Snape on arrival at Hogsmeade. Dumbledore makes sure that Malfoy does not try to kill him. And finally, Dumbledore pleads with Snape; however, he pleads not because he wants to save his life, but, in fact, he pleads because he wants Snape to kill him and go along with the plan, which is why Snape's face is filled with hatred - hatred for himself and what he is just about to do.

Of course, I could be totally wrong about all this but then again I do have seven points. However, this view of the whole thing has a certain charm for me since it proves that Dumbledore didn't die in vain.

The Rest of the Book

The beginning of the book is quite hilarious (I think I count the first, umm, three or four chapters in this) and this general funniness prevails throughout most of the book, making it a joy to read, unlike Book 5, which was a pain in the arse for the major part of the first half. It also thankfully doesn't have a chapter on - or even a mention of - Grawp until the end, and Grawp doesn't have a single dialogue. Good going on that count, Rowling! The romantic part of the book has been done much better than last time. There is a lot more "snogging" and comedy than heart-breaks and awkward moments. Speaking of "snogging", Rowling is just totally obsessed with that word. This book also marks the introduction of the word "slut" into a Harry Potter book.

--Skaran

PS:
An eighth point, which I didn't mention to retain the magical number 7, was that Dumbledore put a freezing charm on Harry. Why? I think it was to prevent Harry from interfering with what was about to happen, as Dumbledore knew he was going to die. Harry obviously wouldn't have let Dumbledore get killed if it was in his power to do something about it.

---

That really makes you think, I wish the 7th book was out

quote:

---

Originally posted by Freaky Guy

quote:

---

I also think that Harry is the final Horcrux, so he will have to kill voldermort (probably at the department of mysteries) and then will fall through the veil in order to finish voldermort off once and for all.

---

impossible....voldy splitted his sould before he went off to kill harry....he couldnt do the horcrux after his body was killed!


okay, i think snapes on the good side....the killing of dumbledore was probabl preplanned...dumbledore knw he was to die..he mentions several times bout old age, maybe thats wat dumbledore and snape were arguiing about....maybe snape didnt want to kill DD. i think that DD asked him to kill so that he doesnt break the unbreakable vow...so that snape didnt die and voldy will then be surely convinced that snapes on his side.

also, snape had so many occasions to kill harry, but he always put off that even in front of other death eaters that harry was to be reserved for voldy, but in the previous books, it was clear voldemort wanted harry dead whoever killed him.

anyway, snape is extremly powerful, his potion books proves it. DD always says death is not the worst thing....i think he must have had very important reasons for getting himself killed. i also think that dumbledore was pleading to snape to kill him just before he died.

just a thought....tel me wat do u think!
also, when harry calls snape a coward, he stops to deny this, cos killing dd would have taken a lot of guts

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Calvin

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Anderton
Originally posted by [url=http://skaran.blogspot.com/2005/07/redeeming-dumbledores-death.html
Karan's Journal[/url]]
Redeeming Dumbledore's Death


Spoiler Warning! As if the title of this web site wasn't warning enough for most people...

So, Dumbledore is dead. Why? There are two, erm, "Points of View" regarding this. One is Harry's, which the book, being focussed as a camera hovering slightly above Harry's head, obviously takes, and, the second is the more rational point of view, which I will discuss here.

In Book 5, Mr. Potter completed his ultimate transformation - he became a painful git. And so, this solidified the fact that, for me, the main hero of the stories became Dumbledore instead of the first two words of the book's title. The notion of Dumbledore's extremely perceptive and receptive brain has been built up with each successive HP title and this book adds to it. I will now go on to explain why I think Dumbledore died of his own free will and did not, as it appears, beg for mercy from S. Snape.

A. P. W. B. Dumbledore is not stupid. This is the salient point throughout my theory and I've believed in this fact since even before the new millennium began. He wouldn't have trusted S. Snape if he didn't have the cold, hard facts on him. Remember how he knew all about Tom Riddle when he came seeking a job at Hogwarts?

Dumbledore knew about the Unforgivable Vow that bound Snape and N. Malfoy. He might have known about this from Snape beforehand and he might have also known what Malfoy intended to do.
Hagrid caught Snape and Dumbledore quarreling at the edge of the forest, and Dumbledore was trying to impress upon Snape, the fact, that he had to do whatever he was told. Also note that they were "quarreling" and not merely talking or discussing as is usually Dumbledore's fashion. This implies that the topic of conversation must be something really big and Dumbledore was forcing Snape to do something that Snape really didn't want to. It could just not be as trivial as investigating Malfoy.
When Potter and Dumbledore returned from the cave, Dumbledore repeatedly asked for Severus Snape and no one else. McGongall and Hagrid were equally trustworthy but he insisted on Snape. Think "Why?".
Also note that, throughout the Cave adventure, Dumbledore kept mentioning how his life was no longer important and that it was Harry who needed to live, not him.
Dumbledore didn't want Draco Malfoy to become a killer. In him, he saw a younger S. Snape and he didn't want him to go over to the Dark side. For this reason, he prevented Draco from killing which would - please excuse me for using Star Wars lingo - complete his transition to the Dark side. He also made sure to ask Malfoy whether any one had been killed and engaged him in conversation until the other Death Eaters had arrived.
When Snape came up to the Astronomy tower, he walked up determinedly. When he got near, his face, as it is mentioned, was filled with hatred. Also, Dumbledore said, in a pleading voice, "... Severus... please...". I just cannot believe that Dumbledore would ever beg for mercy for his life because he was simply unafraid of death. "Death is but the next great adventure", he said to Harry in Harry's first year.
Let's review the information in the light that I shed on it. Dumbledore knew about the Vow and he discussed this with Snape. The plan that Dumbledore chalked out included his own death, and Snape, loyal to Dumbledore, quarreled with him at the edge of the forest because he did not want to kill Dumbledore. Whilst in the cave, Dumbledore impresses upon young Potter about how his own life is no longer important. Dumbledore sends only for Snape on arrival at Hogsmeade. Dumbledore makes sure that Malfoy does not try to kill him. And finally, Dumbledore pleads with Snape; however, he pleads not because he wants to save his life, but, in fact, he pleads because he wants Snape to kill him and go along with the plan, which is why Snape's face is filled with hatred - hatred for himself and what he is just about to do.

Of course, I could be totally wrong about all this but then again I do have seven points. However, this view of the whole thing has a certain charm for me since it proves that Dumbledore didn't die in vain.

The Rest of the Book

The beginning of the book is quite hilarious (I think I count the first, umm, three or four chapters in this) and this general funniness prevails throughout most of the book, making it a joy to read, unlike Book 5, which was a pain in the arse for the major part of the first half. It also thankfully doesn't have a chapter on - or even a mention of - Grawp until the end, and Grawp doesn't have a single dialogue. Good going on that count, Rowling! The romantic part of the book has been done much better than last time. There is a lot more "snogging" and comedy than heart-breaks and awkward moments. Speaking of "snogging", Rowling is just totally obsessed with that word. This book also marks the introduction of the word "slut" into a Harry Potter book.

--Skaran

PS:
An eighth point, which I didn't mention to retain the magical number 7, was that Dumbledore put a freezing charm on Harry. Why? I think it was to prevent Harry from interfering with what was about to happen, as Dumbledore knew he was going to die. Harry obviously wouldn't have let Dumbledore get killed if it was in his power to do something about it.

---

thats makes so much sense!
but all this talk is making me crave the 7th book

---

Alot of you might want to read this while you wait for the new one. It is really good, Sounds just like JK and the story line is real interesting...A bit predictable though.

http://noname.big-blue-fish.com << The PDF File, Its a fan fiction written by some talented writer. It pwnz.

i read the first 100 pages and then got so boored of it that i decided to read the ending parts, and i must say I SUCKS BIG TIME.................i HATE it!!!!!

To Be really honhest, even if snape was good the order wouldnt want him back!

I think im suffering withdrawal symptoms...

Just like i suffered when i finished reading the 5th book

* TD is sad that he has no more Harry Potter left to read

btw, i think that the next book will be a bit weird knowing that they aren't going back to Hogwarts...however, i think that JK will write something that will have to make Harry go back to Hogwarts...

I also wonder how big it will be I hope its huge and full of action

* TD <3's teh Harry Potter books

quote:

---

Originally posted by Third Dimension

btw, i think that the next book will be a bit weird knowing that they aren't going back to Hogwarts...however, i think that JK will write something that will have to make Harry go back to Hogwarts...

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by TylerG

Some people in this thread have mentioned that think Harry will go back to hogwarts to find the horcruxes in Godric Griffindor and the Ravenclaw person possesion's, cuz Dumbledore thought that is where two of the horcruxes were.

---

i love hairy potter but hate reading i havent read the thread but i think ill wait for the movie(im lazy)

i dont actually think she can fit everything into one more book? perhaps there will b more than 7 books? i dont ever remember JKR saying there will only be 7 books exactly..... i also think that DD told Snape to kill him if he was ever in a situation like he was in... waiting for the next book, which JKR said he wasnt going to start for another few months, so she can spend time with her new baby, and other children.. so it might b a couple of year before it is brought out!

quote:

---

Originally posted by lordy16
i dont actually think she can fit everything into one more book? perhaps there will b more than 7 books? i dont ever remember JKR saying there will only be 7 books exactly

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Third Dimension

quote:

---

Originally posted by lordy16
i dont actually think she can fit everything into one more book? perhaps there will b more than 7 books? i dont ever remember JKR saying there will only be 7 books exactly

---

JK said that she would only be making 7 books I wish she could make more, but yeh she only said 7

---

Now, I haven't read any posts so I might not be the forst one with this...
I think Harry is the 7th horcrux. IMO it all makes sense, can't rally explain, I just think it's him.
Now, sorry if someone posted this already.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Vilkku
Now, I haven't read any posts so I might not be the forst one with this...
I think Harry is the 7th horcrux. IMO it all makes sense, can't rally explain, I just think it's him.
Now, sorry if someone posted this already.

---

quote:

---

Written in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

To the Dark Lord
I know thay i will be dead long before you read this
but i want you to know that it was i who discovered your secret.
I have stolen the real Horcrux and intend to destroy it as soon as i can. I face death in hope that when you meet your match,
you will be mortal once more.

R.A.B

---

quote:

---

Written in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
The found an unpleasant-looking silver instrument, something like a many-legged pair of tweezers, which scuttled up Harry's arm like a spider when he picked it up, and attempted to puncture his skin. Sirius seized it and smashed it with a heavy book entitled Nature's Nobility: A Wizarding Genealogy. There was a musical box that emitted a faintly sinister, tinkling tune when wound, and they all found themselves becoming curiously weak and sleepy, until Ginny had the sense to slam it shut; a heavy locket that none of them could open; a number of ancient seals; and in a dusty box, and Order of Merlin, first class, that had been awarded to Sirius's grandfather for 'services at the Ministry'.

---

quote:

---

Written in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
No, he was murdered by Voldermort. Or on Voldermorts orders, more likely; I doubt that Regulus was ever important enough to be killed my Voldermort in person. From what i found out after he died, he got in so far, then panicked about what he was being asked to do and tried to back out. Well you don't just hand in your resignation to Voldermort. It's a lifetime service or death

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Vilkku
Now, I haven't read any posts so I might not be the forst one with this...
I think Harry is the 7th horcrux. IMO it all makes sense, can't rally explain, I just think it's him.
Now, sorry if someone posted this already.

---

I already thought that it would be Regulas but I forgot about the locket. But surely if that was it then it would have been a bit more significant in the 5th book :/

quote:

---

Originally posted by ajd
I already thought that it would be Regulas but I forgot about the locket. But surely if that was it then it would have been a bit more significant in the 5th book :/

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by ajd
But surely if that was it then it would have been a bit more significant in the 5th book :/

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lordy16
i dont think so... JKR adds these things in very cleverly!! you hafta b paying alot of attention to pick this stuff up

---

maybe rab doesnt exist, it may be a nickname only
It is more than posible that RAB he/she is already dead and we will know what is of him
maybe he is dead and we wont see anything of him again
thats my theory
i think jk will make the endin something very very very obvious that we didnt notice

can the killed dumbledore be a magical clone?
maybe it wasnt dumbledore someone else drank polijuice of him..(not likely)
question ! if you die while you are polyjuiced, will you die as the person you morphed to or as yourself?(as you always are)??
thats troubling me now
i cant wait 4 book 7 ....
Maybe RAB is stil alive and will help harry with voldy , as to supply dumby(lol)dore...
as once i heard someone clever, but up to now stupid say
"I have many theories, and all of them as unlikely as each other " undefinedor something like that....

quote:

---

Originally posted by damm-o
if you die while you are polyjuiced, will you die as the person you morphed to or as yourself?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by damm-o
maybe rab doesnt exist, it may be a nickname only

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by damm-o
It is more than posible that RAB he/she is already dead and we will know what is of him

---

alright Im gonna clear up a few things
1. Dumbledore is dead otherwise his portrait would not have appeared in the office
2. Portraits cant think like the original person [as stated in the book]
3.Malfoy is a death eater [all the facts point to it]
4. Harry Cannot be a horcrux because it has to be implmented in a special way once the person is DEAD
5. Harry already said he wasnt going back to school
6. Harry will not die in the 7th book [J.K Rowling said so]
7. She will be killing others in book number 7 [she said so]
8. She said she MAY make more than seven books but doesnt promise anything
9. R.A.B already broke that Horcruz by the looks of it
10. my theory:

R.A.B is Regulus, Sirius will come back because somehow being an animagus made him have to lives, same as James Potter but Voldemort was very strong and was able to kill them both in one shot. Dumbledore is really dead however he left his trails there to help harry.

11. [fact] harry is going to go threw alot of troubles in the next book [J.K Rowling said so]

If I can remember anything else I will post

[ who posted on mugglenet? Ive been getting some facts from their interview with Johanne]

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
alright Im gonna clear up a few things
1. Dumbledore is dead otherwise his portrait would not have appeared in the office

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
2. Portraits cant think like the original person [as stated in the book]

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
3.Malfoy is a death eater [all the facts point to it]

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
4. Harry Cannot be a horcrux because it has to be implmented in a special way once the person is DEAD

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
5. Harry already said he wasnt going back to school

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
6. Harry will not die in the 7th book

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
7. She will be killing others in book number 7

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
8. She said she MAY make more than seven books but doesnt promise anything

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
9. R.A.B already broke that Horcruz by the looks of it

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
Sirius will come back because somehow being an animagus made him have to lives, same as James Potter but Voldemort was very strong and was able to kill them both in one shot. Dumbledore is really dead however he left his trails there to help harry.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
11. [fact] harry is going to go threw alot of troubles in the next book

---

JKR has already said that she will not introduce any new major characters in book 7, and I think that the person who stole Voldermort's horcrux would be considered major, so I think R.A.B. is Regelus Black.

Regulus is said to be dead, but he may or may not be, as they never found him , its just a rumor..
but WHO KNOWS, i will give anything to know everything about hp7 on        JKR mind...

quote:

---

Originally posted by Tasha
    quoteriginally posted by lou_habs
    2. Portraits cant think like the original person [as stated in the book]



WHERE exactly is that stated in the book?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs

quote:

---

Originally posted by Tasha
    quoteriginally posted by lou_habs
    2. Portraits cant think like the original person [as stated in the book]



WHERE exactly is that stated in the book?

---

Well let me find the page.... I will state back on that once I found it. but it IS stated.

---

I think that it is sirius' brother aswell (R.A.B), I was even reading through the book for the name. I doubt it was somebody who didn't like him, because otherwise, they wouldn't have called him the "dark lord".

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
4. Harry Cannot be a horcrux because it has to be implmented in a special way once the person is DEAD

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
5. Harry already said he wasnt going back to school

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by lou_habs
8. She said she MAY make more than seven books but doesnt promise anything

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Vazza
Where was this stated? And it would a nice twist in the tale if it was so. Who is to say (except JK) that when Harry was left with the scar (in which it was believed that some of Voldamort's power transfered to Harry) that part of his soul was left too?

---

maybe he will...I| doubt it but everythingis possible its magic!

Sigh...

Slughorn said that you have to kill someone before you can rip your soul apart, but it is your choice as to when you take a bit of your soul out, as Voldemort sure as hell hasnt killed only 6 people. (the 7th part is still in him).

Once you have chosen to take a part of your soul out, you can implement it into anything to keep it safe. It doesn't automatically go into the person you have killed. You choose to put it into an object.

And to quote myself on Harry being the final Horcrux:

quote:

---

Originally posted by Tasha
I do not believe Harry is a Horcrux. I mean, Voldemort would have to be reliant on something that isn't in his control. And what if harry got killed? And why would Voldemort always be trying to kill Harry, if he was a Horcrux? It would be killing yourself.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Tasha
Sigh...

Slughorn said that you have to kill someone before you can rip your soul apart, but it is your choice as to when you take a bit of your soul out, as Voldemort sure as hell hasnt killed only 6 people. (the 7th part is still in him).

Once you have chosen to take a part of your soul out, you can implement it into anything to keep it safe. It doesn't automatically go into the person you have killed. You choose to put it into an object.

And to quote myself on Harry being the final Horcrux:

quote:

---

Originally posted by Tasha
I do not believe Harry is a Horcrux. I mean, Voldemort would have to be reliant on something that isn't in his control. And what if harry got killed? And why would Voldemort always be trying to kill Harry, if he was a Horcrux? It would be killing yourself.

---

Oh, and also, there are only 7 Horcrux's, and both Dumbledore and Voldemort and Harry know all about them. I'm sure if Harry was a Horcrux, or it was suspected that he could be, Dumbledore would have told him.

---

I think Malfoys a death eater.

I dunno about the neding it was ok! i still think they'll end up going to back hogwarts! Harry and Ginny should of stayed                  together!

Lol yeah Malfoy is deffinatly a deatheater especially because his parents were, and i think the (Parents of) Crabbe and Goyle were too, cant remember....

anyways anymore of those funny spoiler videos

i dont think hes a death eater...it hasnt been mentioned anywhere in the book.....and thats something considering Rowling...if he was a death eater..some mention of his dark mark would surely have been there(there always have been, the deatheaters, snape, karkarrof)..its clearly said that he has to do the job cos his father was a letdown!

Im not going to quote what tasha said before cus its to long.
But seriously people were just giving ideas about what they thaught and that person just told what he knew because there was confusion.

All you did was say "Smart one Einstien" how does that help with both the persons moral and the forums, thats almost grounds for spam..

Still you were just trying to make a post and all you said pretty much "Oh Really?"

quote:

---

Originally posted by michael_m91
Im not going to quote what tasha said before cus its to long.
But seriously people were just giving ideas about what they thaught and that person just told what he knew because there was confusion.

All you did was say "Smart one Einstien" how does that help with both the persons moral and the forums, thats almost grounds for spam..

Still you were just trying to make a post and all you said pretty much "Oh Really?"

---

well yea...she was just being a lil sarcastic..wats wrong wid that..and we have gone completely off topic here

I already said to get back on topic, we've sorted everything out in PM's and now that im trying to get back on topic... again, does anybody know anymore of those funny spoiler videos like that one that the guy yells out?

When I was reading the book for about the tenth time It said that his wand hand was black and shriveled up. I looked on the front cover and there´s Dumbledore holding his wand but his hand isnt black and shivrelled up.


P.S I´m writing this from a internet cafe (in spain as i´m on holiday) I´ve been waiting to get on for about 3 hours!

who really cares bout the cover!!