Shoutbox

quote:

---

Originally posted by saralk
We don't know why Dumbledore trusted Snape so much, in the face of so much stuff, Dumbledore never once doubted Snape's excuse for why he told Voldy about the prophecy.

---

Good point actually. He at least listened to Harry's other points but always insisted that he trusted Snape.  He knew about Malfoy but never said about it because of tres clever reasons and it would be pretty obvious for him to see about snape.

Whoever replaced the horcrux with a fake one will be quite significant in the next book. It'll probably clear up some stuff about snape killing dumbledore as well.

Who do you lot think is R.A.B ?
I think its Regulas Black.

JK Rowling said something big would be revealed in book 6 about Lily, nothing besides "she was great at potions" is revealed.

I think Snape is still a bad guy because Dumbledore did not tell him to kill him before the unbreakable vow.

Maybe Harry will survive in the last book, but someone close to him will die once again.

Harry may return to Hogwarts for some reason or another where we will know the new defence against dark arts teacher.

There is a member of the Order of the Phoenix which will play a big role in book 7. He has been introduced but not very highly.

Snape and Malfoy i think both die.

quote:

---

Originally posted by hmaster5
Snape and Malfoy i think both die.

---

I have been waiting for both of them to die, that is great info.

What are people's opinions on whether Malfoy is a death eater or not? It didn't actually say.

I think Malfoy is a death eater.  Even though I don't think he can handle it.

I think Lily Potter had something to do with the Half-Blood Prince.
Hermione kept saying it could of been a girl, the handwriting was supposedly girly and the Potions teacher (forgot the name) kept saying Harry had the same techniques as his Mother.
Perhaps Lily Potter and Snape 'got it on' and she helped him in Potions

It would explain why Snape and James hated each other so much :/

Although it's not very likely

quote:

---

Originally posted by Jimcando
Perhaps Lily Potter and Snape 'got it on' and she helped him in Potions

---

That is a very good idea Seriously though, she might have something to do with the halfblood prince.  But I doubt it because Harry said that Snape called his mom a filthy mud-blood. 

yeh he is, or more importanty was made to be for Lucius's stupid mistakes.

Bellatrix and Pettigrew didnt do much.

Lily defended Snape, if you remember in the Pensieve. Maybe Snape was in love with her and he used to tell her his secrets. Thats why he hated James.

And Harrys mum kept sticking up for Snape.