Shoutbox

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Anderton
And couldnt dd have a horcrux thingy

---

you have to kill to make a horcrux, but like you said, you have not read the book

jk rowling said that the last few pages will give clues for the next book. i guess that harry is not returning to hogwarts

i have not read the thread nor the first post. sry. just too tired from school

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Anderton
And i think dd isnt gone as next year there will be a new 'hm' for hogwarts (assuming the school is open cause else it'll be dodgy or really exciting ) (How do you make a hp book with out all that school stuff ..... the book will be really full of lotsa content then but its unlikely )
DD isnt gone imo ..... he is said to be one of the greatest wizards of his / all tim

---

imo, he's definately gone because we saw him get buried. McGonnagle. Anyway, he won't be at Hogwarts next year because he, Ron and Hermione are looking for the horcruxes.

after bill and fleurs wedding, where somethign could happen

This brings up another question: Will book 7 have "Year 7" on the side of the book like the rest of the books, and if so, What does it mean?

i think he will go back to hogwarts to look for the Gryfindor/Ravenclaw Horcrux

quote:

---

Originally posted by hmaster5
Dumbledore also said the prophecy may or may not be true. Imagine if Harry didnt know about the prophecy. Do all prophecys come true?

The prophecy really just egged Harry on. He really just wants Voldy dead for revenge.

---

Dumble said that the prophecy is true because voldemorte made it true.  If there wasn't a prophecy then Harry would have an ordinary life.  But Voldemorte trying to prevent the prophecy from coming true made it come true.

Personally I don't think Dumbledore will be coming back. It would be a bit of a poor ending if he somehow came back to life. Might as well just bring everyone back to life, like Harry's parents. Bit of a cop out really

I'm not so convinced that Sirius Black is dead to be honest. His "death" was a bit vague I think - I expect him to make an appearance in book 7.

Finally I am convinced that Snape isn't a bad guy. It would make good book writing for JK Rowling to try to make everyone believe that Snape was a bad guy all along, but in actual fact it turns out that he is actually good. Dumbledore never stated why he trusted Snape so absolutely, but I think he was right. Dumbledore was one of the wisest and greatest wizards ever - he wouldn't make a mistake as big as that

quote:

---

he wouldn't make a mistake as big as that 

---

thats wat i think too!

quote:

---

Originally posted by FrozernFire
you have to kill to make a horcrux, but like you said, you have not read the book

---

Oh yeah .... i heard that too
Couldnt dd have killed someone evil for it
<3 dd R.I.P (i guess )

Imo if there is school next year then the hm has to be mrs. mcgonagal

quote:

---

Originally posted by John Anderton

quote:

---

Originally posted by FrozernFire
you have to kill to make a horcrux, but like you said, you have not read the book

---

Oh yeah .... i heard that too
Couldnt dd have killed someone evil for it
<3 dd R.I.P (i guess )

Imo if there is school next year then the hm has to be mrs. mcgonagal

---

it is DARK ARTS...its sooo dark that it has no mention even in the hogwarts library......dd couldnt have learned such dark magic...or even if he did knw, he wouldnt use it!