Shoutbox

quote:

---

Originally posted by jpg050
Catalán is also a Spanish dialect...

---

I don't think so. About Valencian being a Catalan dialect... that can be argued, but in my opinion Catalan isn't a dialect (or at least, not so dialect from spanish as valencan could be from catalan). I mean, valencian is more similar to catalan than catalan to spanish

quote:

---

Originally posted by jpg050
Catalán is also a Spanish dialect...

---

CATALAN is not a spanish dialect. It's a language. A lot of people consideer Catalan a dialect of Spanish, but that's not true... Spanish people want to delete Catalan language and culture....

Hi ha gent a qui no li agrada que es pensi, es llegeixi o s'escrigui en català. És la mateixa gent a qui no li agrada que es llegeixi, s'escrigui o es pensi.
There's a lot of people who don't like others to read, write or think in Catalan. That's usually the same people who don't like to read, write or think. (THAT WAS SAID BY A VALENCIAN AUTHOR, who thought that Catalan and Valencian are the same).

quote:

---

Originally posted by jpg050
I don't see a reason for Valencian to be removed...

---

I'm not asking for Valencian to be removed, I only want to know why!! I have nothing against Valencian people, except that ones who think in strange ways (or that's they believe, that they think).


SENSE VALÈNCIA NO HI HA INDEPENDÈNCIA!!! |¡*¡| VISCA CATALUNYA LLIURE!!!

Creo que este thread se esta saliendo de cauce. Ya se discutió una vez sobre eso y ahora lo unico que importa (si acaso) es que Patchou explique porqué decidió incluir la traducción valenciana en Plus! Voy a "reportear" este thread pidiendo a los moderadores que lo cierren.

I think this thread is getting offtopic. There is another about the same thing and now what really matters is what Patchou has to say (if he wants to say something about why he added the Valencian translation). I'm going to report this thread asking the mods to close it.