Shoutbox

btw, why where my posts deleted? there was nothing wrong, it was shawnz' i reported..... should i repost =/? rofl

Which, i forgot to mention, makes this guy a liar

quote:

---

Originally posted by wannabe hacker

It's amazing to see how much people inside the company have copies and drafts of this book.

---

i do 2. i mean if harry was a horcrux then he would hav 2 kill himself 2 kill voldemort and tht wouldnt work bcuz ifhe commited suicide then who would kill voldemort. the prophecy clearly says harry iz the ONLY ONE who can kill voldemort

quote:

---

Originally posted by the_rebellion
iz ne1 even lokkin at this Thread?

---

can you shut the fuck up? seriously

I like the muggle theory, i dont want harry to die..

Okay, What do you guys think will happen?


I want Luna and Neville to get together, they are just so clumsily cute together (gay, i know)
I want to see little redheads at the end of the book.
I want Harry Potter to die.
I wanna see bushy haired kids.
I wanna see another bad guy.
I wanna see the story repeat.


I think I'm going to be dissapointed, I expect too much.

Edit:
I can't wait anyway, I'm sure some plot twist will make it worth the wait.

Dumbledore will not come back from the dead, there was no elabroate trick involving dumbledore's animagous being a phoenix or anything. The simple reason is that JKR does follow traditional literary conventions and almost all great stories have the hero facing his/her nemesis alone

Also, I personally think that Snape:

a) heard the whole prophecy and only gave enough information to Voldemort in order to make him go after Harry, therby handing the world the weapon of his own demise.

b) is working for himself, choosing to play the order and the death eaters against each other, giving select information in order to gain favour in both circles and ultimately emerge as the one true victor. (I also think that it'd be nice poetically if it ends with three people, all of whom have had troubled childhoods [we saw from the pensive and the glimpse into Snape's mind that he was beaten as a child and bullied], each fighting each other for their own beliefs.

quote:

---

Originally posted by saralk
Dumbledore will not come back from the dead, there was no elabroate trick involving dumbledore's animagous being a phoenix or anything.

---

Exactly!

quote:

---

Originally posted by saralk
b) is working for himself, choosing to play the order and the death eaters against each other, giving select information in order to gain favour in both circles and ultimately emerge as the one true victor.

---

I agree, you've got a good theory

edit:
and i think you're probably right...

JK recently said (on Jonathan Ross?) that she MIGHT continue the story years and years from now, so killing Harry would seriously mess up her ideas... (if he was dead and she carried on, she couldn't call them "Harry Potter" books anymore, but just books set in the same world)

I had theory when I read  HBP that the pheonix was important. Authors these days don't tend to fill pages with useless events. It's nearly all relevant.

I don't think Snape is evil still. I think he knows something that we don't... (He's my favourite character just because of the actor in the films )

As for people dying, it's most likely going to be Snape and Voldemort to go in this one.

This is just a theory but:
To come back as a ghost, you have to have left some kind of mark (or impression) on the world. Harry looks like his father (but with his mother's eyes ), meaning that they might play an important part in the next book? It might also be a way for Dumbledore to come back and run Hogwarts as a (the first) ghost headmaster

I doubt Dumbledore will come back, because Harry saw dumbledore in the portrait in the headmasters office. And I'm sure he'd already be a ghost otherwise.

quote:

---

Originally posted by SpunkyLoveMuff
JK recently said (on Jonathan Ross?) that she MIGHT continue the story years and years from now,

---

If we are talking about the same interview, she said "Never said never"...

quote:

---

Originally posted by Napbree
I doubt Dumbledore will come back, because Harry saw dumbledore in the portrait in the headmasters office. And I'm sure he'd already be a ghost otherwise.

---

Where have you been the last year?
JKR said that Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore is no more, he's dead, dead, dead and is not coming back. That doesn't mean he didn't leave something for Harry, JKR told Daniel Raddcliff that Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore was giving her much trouble...

quote:

---

Originally posted by Voldemort
    quoteriginally posted by Napbree
    I doubt Dumbledore will come back, because Harry saw dumbledore in the portrait in the headmasters office. And I'm sure he'd already be a ghost otherwise.



Where have you been the last year?
JKR said that Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore is no more, he's dead, dead, dead and is not coming back. That doesn't mean he didn't leave something for Harry, JKR told Daniel Raddcliff that Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore was giving her much trouble...

---

Yeah, thats why I said I doubt he'd come back... and dumbledores portrait IS in the headmasters office. What I was trying to say was to Spunky... That Dumbledore wont come back as a ghost because he's already a portrait.