Shoutbox

My thoughts on CookieRevised's points:

quote:

---

Originally posted by CookieRevised
* Can one vote for the same post multiple times?

---

No. If it's extremely good, then bleh, people will notice. If it's bad, use the report button.

quote:

---

Originally posted by CookieRevised
* What if that post gots edited, is it considered a new post where you can vote on it again or not?

---

I mostly only edit posts to correct my spelling or add an additional point or something. If it changes the whole theme of what is said, there was probably a reason to vote as you did before, so you don't need to vote again.

quote:

---

Originally posted by CookieRevised
* What if you want to change your vote for a certain post?

---

Depends how hard it is for WDZ to code, and how lazy he's feeling. As I said there shouldn't really be a need to change your vote.

quote:

---

Originally posted by CookieRevised
* If you vote for individual posts, maybe it is an idea to have two reputation bars: 1 for the individual post, 1 for the poster himself.

---

Not too sure what you mean?

quote:

---

Originally posted by CookieRevised
* What if a post gots deleted; does this delete also the votes for it and so the votes for the poster himself?

---

Maybe there could be an option for the admins? For example, if the starter of a thread deletes it, he can keep whatever points he's lost/gained, but if an admin/mod deletes it, they can choose what happens? (This is why I didn't refer to your fourth point, by the way...)

quote:

---

Originally posted by CookieRevised
* Maybe if a post gots moved to T&T or deleted by an admin, the reputation of that poster (and/or post) should decrease.

---

Again, they could choose. And of course, reputation should not be counted in T&T.


Edit: oops, sorry, didn't see this post:

quote:

---

Originally posted by bach_m
maybe, but i dont think it will be THAT much of a problem. i mean, if some of the 20 are away, wouldn't it make sence that there are a proportionately smaller amount of posts???? the 20 are just like others, just with a bit more power

---

Why...? There are 20 people, and granted they post a lot, but we have thousands of members. If two are away, it doesn't mean there will be 90% of the normal number of posts. Mostly I don't post because one of them has, so I reckon there will be the same number of posts, if not more.