quote:
Originally posted by Johnny_Mac
quote:
Originally posted by Guido
I don't get it... we have spent about a week discussing this and now you think we just don't need it?
I never expressed my views about it until now... so cause I didnt say anything in the first place I should just go along with it? Great discussion!
And the point of discussing is to share points of view, I did and Lob happened to see a point of view, whats wrong with that? 
You are completely right. I now realise I sounded rude
, it wasn't my intention. The fact that after discussing during days about how to implement reputations to help users a couple of users come and say it's not necessary put me nervous
Sorry
quote:
Originally posted by billywoods1
Idea: how about a 'report comment' button, if the comments are added? Could just be the 'report' button at the bottom-right of the posts... but next to each comment. That way if they're abusive or something, or heavily biased because of personal conflicts, they can be reported to mods/admins.
Yes, that should be definitely be implemented, it would dramatically help comments moderating.
quote:
I also like CookieRevised's idea of 14 days, a month is a bit long
Now that I think of it, you're right: if a new user was treated badly by someone and he wants to comment about him, he should have the right to.
quote:
Originally posted by BillyWoods1
Nope. I'm afraid one person is gonna vote people unfairly, or sway their opinions, and so they should have a right to have a say. Also, free speech? 
I mean, this could very easily turn into races - the first person to get +1 could vote others as -1, and therefore stop them from being able to post... well, you get the idea, anyway. I think everyone should have a right to an opinion.
Well said
quote:
Edit: new thing. Should the list of votes for a person's reputation show the voters' current reputations or their reputations at the time? Or both? I don't like the idea of at the time, but think about the others...
Current one, for sure.
Otherwise
a. it would be extremely confusing to see different reputations in every post.
b. the database would have to store the reputation of the user at every post he posts.
/ 
