Shoutbox

Ok,

well today we did a little tricky thing, though no one in the class expected it to be trickable

We got a paper and it said this

Intructions
Read All The Lines Carefully.

then under that line it said

Follow the instructions exactly.

So what it says above is too

[Instructions] = Read The Lines Carefully (So what they say is too read the lines, but do not DO them)

[Instructions2] = Follow the intructions exactly! (Which means, follow the instructions which means too Read the lines below carefully )

And so

Nobody knew it meant that.

They thought it was, read the lines below and DO them.

So,

The lines below were like this

1. Create A Rectangle with a Circle in it and a triangle on the other side of the page

2. Write the country you were born in backwards.

3. <blah>

4. <blah>
.
.
.
.

All the way too #9

If you have done all the steps succesfully yell out "I am doing good"

(This is the point we all hear people yelling that out, around 15 minutes later, since they did the other steps before)

Then all the way too #10

10. Now if you have completed and did everything EXACTLY as said say "I have completed this exactly and correctly"

So.

In the end we found out that we did not need to all those steps, we just had too read them .

So then people started complaining that they did not explain.

Anyways, our teacher explained what I said above.

quote:

---

We got a paper and it said this

Intructions
Read All The Lines Carefully.

then under that line it said

Follow the instructions exactly.

So what it says above is too

[Instructions] = Read The Lines Carefully (So what they say is too read the lines, but do not DO them)

[Instructions2] = Follow the intructions exactly! (Which means, follow the instructions which means too Read the lines below carefully )

---

So, then the teacher said "You did not need to write down anything, I should have heard you all say "I am doing good" and "I have completed this exactly and correctly""

So then she said "What I said is right, just shows that no student read anything correctly." So then I complained that if we were supposed to just read them, then we did not need too yell out those things as it was part of the steps.

So yeah, though I made sence I think, I had too stay after school for a few minutes.

My question is, is my logic right ?

If we just needed to read the questions then would you need to talk out those words?

I had this test the last year
i felt so stupid
only 3 people understood it before doing anything

quote:

---

Originally posted by SonicSam
My question is, is my logic right (Smilie)?

If we just needed to read the questions then would you need to talk out those words?

---

imho (and strange logic) I would say you were absolutely correct and the teacher not

Hmm, those lines numbered 1 to 10 were part of the instructions? If so, the instructions clearly state "Write the country you were born in backwards"... so you DO have to write things down.

Following instructions means executing/doing them.... if instructions say you need to write something, you write something... if instructions say you need to say something you say something... if instructions say you should tell your teacher she doesn't make any sense at all you should, well you get the point .

quote:

---

Originally posted by MenthiX
Hmm, those lines numbered 1 to 10 were part of the instructions? If so, the instructions clearly state "Write the country you were born in backwards"... so you DO have to write things down.

Following instructions means executing/doing them.... if instructions say you need to write something, you write something... if instructions say you need to say something you say something... if instructions say you should tell your teacher she doesn't make any sense at all you should, well you get the point .

---

But those were not intructions, the intructions were to do read the lines which is the lines that tell you too do something.

For example.

If the intructions said "Read the next line"

And here is the next line.

"Draw a cookie"

It does not mean I had to draw a cookie, I just read that it says "Draw a cookie

quote:

---

Originally posted by CookieRevised

quote:

---

Originally posted by SonicSam
My question is, is my logic right (Smilie)?

If we just needed to read the questions then would you need to talk out those words?

---

imho (and strange logic) I would say you were absolutely correct and the teacher not

---

yay

quote:

---

Originally posted by SonicSam
If the intructions said "Read the next line"

And here is the next line.

"Draw a cookie"

---

not really.
they are pointing you to the next instruction
so you draw a cookie
it does not say read the next line but don't do it..

I did this like 8 years ago in primary school

Our sheet was a little different and worded something like:
"Before you begin ensure that you read the steps below completely"

Of course, most people still fell for it.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Chris Boulton
"Before you begin ensure that you read the steps below completely"

---

I had one that said that and at the end say don't do anything...

those test are so stupid...
most off the time there is a flaw in their own logic...
and when you are finished the teacher points out that didn't have to do the things listed...
but when you state you wanted to do it because you where bored the teacher normally gets pissed...

quote:

---

Originally posted by foaly
but when you state you wanted to do it because you where bored the teacher normally gets pissed...

---

Exactly